Abstract
Purpose
The aim of this work is to evaluate the potential of combining different computer-aided detection (CADe) methods to increase the actual support for radiologists of automated systems in the identification of pulmonary nodules in CT scans.
Methods
The outputs of three different CADe systems developed by researchers of the Italian MAGIC-5 collaboration were combined. The systems are: the CAMCADe (based on a Channeler-Ant-Model which segments vessel tree and nodule candidates and a neural classifier), the RGVPCADe (a Region-Growing- Volume-Plateau algorithm detects nodule candidates and a neural network reduces false positives); the VBNACADe (two dedicated procedures, based respectively on a 3D dot-enhancement algorithm and on intersections of pleura surface normals, identifies internal and juxtapleural nodules, and a Voxel-Based-Neural-Approach reduces false positives. A dedicated OsiriX plugin implemented with the Cocoa environments of MacOSX allows annotating nodules and visualizing singles and combined CADe findings.
Results
The combined CADe has been tested on thin slice (lower than 2 mm) CTs of the LIDC public research database and the results have been compared with those obtained by the single systems. The FROC (Free Receiver Operating Characteristic) curves show better results than the best of the single approaches.
Conclusions
Has been demonstrated that the combination of different approaches offers better results than each single CADe system. A clinical validation of the combined CADe as second reader is being addressed by means of the dedicated OsiriX plugin.
This is a preview of subscription content, log in via an institution to check access.
Similar content being viewed by others
References
Online document. American Cancer Society (2009) http://www.cancer.org/Research/CancerFactsFigures. Accessed 16 December 2010
Ferlay J, Shin HR, Bray F, Forman D, Mathers C, Parkin DM (2010) Estimates of worldwide burden of cancer in 2008. Int J Cancer 117(12): 2893–2917
Diederich S, Lentschig MG, Overbeck TR, Wormanns D, Heindel W (2001) Detection of pulmonary nodules at spiral CT: comparison of maximum intensity projection sliding slabs and single-image reporting. European Radiology 11(8): 1345–1350
Investigators The International Early Lung Cancer Action Program: (2006) Survival of patients with stage I lung cancer detected on CT screening. New England J Med 355(17): 1763–1771
Online document U.S. National Cancer Institute November (2010) http://www.cancer.gov/clinicaltrials/noteworthy-trials/nlst. Accessed 16 December 2010
Roberts HC, Patsios D, Kucharczyk DM, Paul N, Roberts TP (2005) The utility of computer-aided detection (CAD) for lung cancer screening using low-dose CT, Computer Assisted Radiology and Surgery, Proceedings of the 19th International Congress and Exhibition, Berlin, June 22–25, 2005, International Congress Series 1281, pp 1137–1142
Das M et al (2006) Small pulmonary nodules: effect of two computer-aided detection systems on radiologist performance. Radiology 241: 564–571
Brochu B et al (2007) Computer-aided detection of lung nodules on thin collimation MDCT: impact on radiologists’ performance. Journal de Radiologie 88(4): 573–578
Matsumoto S et al (2008) Computer-aided detection of lung nodules on multidetector row computed tomography using three-dimensional analysis of nodule candidates and their surroundings. Radiat Med 26(9): 562–569
van Ginneken B, Armato SG 3rd, de Hoop B, Amelsvoort-van Vorst S, Duindam T, Niemeijer M, Murphy K, Schilham A, Retico A, Fantacci ME, Camarlinghi N, Bagagli F, Gori I, Hara T, Fujita H, Gargano G, Bellotti R, Tangaro S, Bolaños L, De Carlo F, Cerello P, Cristian Cheran S, Lopez Torres E, Prokop M (2010) Comparing and combining algorithms for computer-aided detection of pulmonary nodules in computed tomography scans: the ANODE09 study. Med Image Anal 14(6): 707–722
Niemeijer M, Loog M, Abràmoff MD, Viergever MA, Prokop M, van Ginneken B (2011) On combining computer-aided detection systems. IEEE Trans Med Imaging 30(2): 215–223
Bellotti R et al (2007) Distributed medical images analysis on a GRID infrastructure. Future Gener Comput Syst 23: 475–484
Golosio B et al (2009) A novel multithreshold method for nodule detection in lung CT. Med Phys 36(8): 3607–3618
De Nunzio G et al (2009) Automatic lung segmentation in CT images with accurate handling of the Hilar region. J Digit Imaging, Online First
Cerello P, Cheran SC, Bagagli F, Bagnasco S, Bellotti R, Bolanos L, Catanzariti E, De Nunzio G, Fiorina E, Gargano G, Gemme G, Lopez Torres E, Masala G, Peroni C and Santoro M (2008) The Channeler Ant Model: object segmentation with virtual ant colonies. In: IEEE nuclear science symposium conference records, 2008, 3147–3152
Cerello P et al (2010) 3-D object segmentation using ant colonies. Pattern Recognit 43(4): 1476–1490
Fantacci ME et al Computer aided detection of nodules in low dose and thin slice lung CT. doi:10.1594/ecr2010/C-1053
Bellotti R et al (2007) A CAD system for nodule detection in low-dose lung CTs based on region growing and a new active contour model. Med Phys 34(12): 4901–4910
Retico A, Delogu P, Fantacci ME, Gori I, Preite Martinez A (2008) Lung nodule detection in low-dose and thin-slice computed tomography. Comput Biol Med 38(4): 525–534
Gori I, Bagagli F, Fantacci ME, Preite Martinez A, Retico A, De Mitri I, Donadio S, Fulcheri C, Gargano G, Magro R, Santoro M, Stumbo S (2007) Multi-scale analysis of lung computed tomography images. J Instrum 2(09):P09007
Retico A, Fantacci ME, Gori I, Kasae P, Golosio B, Piccioli A, Cerello P, De Nunzio G, Tangaro S (2009) Pleural nodule identification il low-dose and thin-slice lung computed tomography. Comput Biol Med 39(12): 1137–1144
Retico A et al (2009) A voxel-based neural approach (VBNA) to identify lung nodules in the ANODE09 study. Proc SPIE, vol. 7260, 72601S-72601S-8
McNitt-Gray MF, Armato SG 3rd, Meyer CR, Reeves AP, McLennan G, Pais RC, Freymann J, Brown MS, Engelmann RM, Bland PH, Laderach GE, Piker C, Guo J, Towfic Z, Qing DP, Yankelevitz DF, Aberle DR, van Beek EJ, MacMahon H, Kazerooni EA, Croft BY, Clarke LP (2007) The lung image database consortium (LIDC) data collection process for nodule detection and annotation. Acad Radiol 14(12): 1464–1474
https://wiki.nci.nih.gov/display/cip/lidc. Accessed 16 december 2010
Fukunaga K (1990) Introduction to statistical pattern recognition. Academic Press, New York
Stone M (1974) Cross-validatory choice and assessment of statistical predictions. J R Stat Soc B 36(1): 111–147
Retico A, Bagagli F, Camarlinghi N, Carpentieri C, Fantacci ME, Gori I (2009) A voxel-based neural approach (VBNA) to identify lung nodules in the ANODE09 study. In: Medical Imaging 2009: Computer-Aided Diagnosis, 7260, 72601S–8, SPIE, Lake Buena Vista, FL, USA
Li Q, Sone S, Doi K (2003) Selective enhancement filters for nodules, vessels, and airway walls in two- and three-dimensional CT scans. Med Phys 30(8): 2040–2051
Paik SD, Beaulieu CF, Rubin GD, Acar B, Jeffrey RB Jr, Yee J, Dey J, Napel S (2004) Surface normal overlap: A computer-aided detection algorithm with application to colonic polyps and lung nodules in helical CT. IEEE Trans Med Imaging 23(6): 661–675
http://www.osirix-viewer.com/. Accessed 16 december 2010
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Camarlinghi, N., Gori, I., Retico, A. et al. Combination of computer-aided detection algorithms for automatic lung nodule identification. Int J CARS 7, 455–464 (2012). https://doi.org/10.1007/s11548-011-0637-6
Received:
Accepted:
Published:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s11548-011-0637-6