Pseudo-Scientist: Towards Narrative Interventions for Imposter Syndrome
Authors: 
Katelyn M. Grasse, Nic Junius, Kevin Weatherwax, Shweta Sisodiya, Amanda Martin, Elin CarstensdottirAuthors Info & Claims
Katelyn M. Grasse, Nic Junius, Kevin Weatherwax, Shweta Sisodiya, Amanda Martin, Elin CarstensdottirAuthors Info & ClaimsArticle No.: 334, Pages 1 - 29
Abstract
Imposter syndrome (IS) is a mental state that can severely inhibit a person's productivity and well-being. Although IS is extremely common (especially in high achievers, e.g., academics), few studies offer effective modes of support and recovery. In response, we introduce the application of relatable narrative as a way to help people overcome IS. We present a randomized group comparison study exploring the impact of various design factors -- specifically, choice-based interactivity and character relatability -- on our story's capacity to engage and impact 107 STEM undergraduates. Almost all participants enthusiastically endorsed the story as a valuable learning experience, and a majority reported positive impacts to mood and feelings of relatedness to peers. We discuss 1) how our specific digital story design can support positive changes in mental health at both individual and institutional levels and 2) how our findings can inform efficient design of interactive narrative content for educational applications.
References
[1]
Ruth S Aylett, Sandy Louchart, Joao Dias, Ana Paiva, and Marco Vala. 2005. FearNot!--an experiment in emergent narrative. In Intelligent Virtual Agents: 5th International Working Conference, IVA 2005, Kos, Greece, September 12--14, 2005. Proceedings 5. Springer, 305--316.
[2]
Jack J Bauer and Dan P McAdams. 2000. Competence, relatedness, and autonomy in life stories. Psychological Inquiry, Vol. 11, 4 (2000), 276--279.
[3]
Natalie Baumann, Carol Faulk, Jessica Vanderlan, Justin Chen, and Rakhee K Bhayani. 2020. Small-group discussion sessions on imposter syndrome. MedEdPORTAL, Vol. 16 (2020), 11004.
[4]
Naijean S Bernard, Stephen J Dollinger, and Nerella V Ramaniah. 2002. Applying the big five personality factors to the impostor phenomenon. Journal of Personality Assessment, Vol. 78, 2 (2002), 321--333.
[5]
Joel Bothello and Thomas J Roulet. 2019. The imposter syndrome, or the mis-representation of self in academic life. Journal of Management Studies, Vol. 56, 4 (2019), 854--861.
[6]
Virginia Braun and Victoria Clarke. 2012. Thematic analysis.American Psychological Association.
[7]
Dena M Bravata, Sharon A Watts, Autumn L Keefer, Divya K Madhusudhan, Katie T Taylor, Dani M Clark, Ross S Nelson, Kevin O Cokley, and Heather K Hagg. 2020. Prevalence, predictors, and treatment of impostor syndrome: a systematic review. Journal of General Internal Medicine, Vol. 35 (2020), 1252--1275.
[8]
Sarah Anne Brown and Sharon Lynn Chu. 2021. 'You Write Your Own Story': Design Implications for an Interactive Narrative Authoring Tool to Support Reflection for Mental Health in College Students. In Interactive Storytelling: 14th International Conference on Interactive Digital Storytelling, ICIDS 2021, Tallinn, Estonia, December 7--10, 2021, Proceedings 14. Springer, 312--321.
[9]
Janelynn Camingue, Edward F Melcer, and Elin Carstensdottir. 2020. A (visual) novel route to learning: a taxonomy of teaching strategies in visual novels. In Proceedings of the 15th International Conference on the Foundations of Digital Games. 1--13.
[10]
Nicky Case, Monplaisir, and Spacie. 2019. Adventures With Anxiety! [Web Browser], Canada.
[11]
Alaina Chodoff, Lynae Conyers, Scott Wright, and Rachel Levine. 2023. 'I never should have been a doctor': a qualitative study of imposter phenomenon among internal medicine residents. BMC Medical Education, Vol. 23, 1 (2023), 1--8.
[12]
Katheryn R Christy, Matthew Minich, Ran Tao, Karyn Riddle, and Sunghak Kim. 2022. To tailor or not to tailor: An investigation of narrative tailoring for health communication. Journal of Health Communication, Vol. 27, 3 (2022), 152--163.
[13]
Pauline Rose Clance and Suzanne Ament Imes. 1978. The imposter phenomenon in high achieving women: Dynamics and therapeutic intervention. Psychotherapy: Theory, Research & Practice, Vol. 15, 3 (1978), 241.
[14]
Jonathan Cohen. 2001. Defining identification: A theoretical look at the identification of audiences with media characters. Mass Communication & Society, Vol. 4, 3 (2001), 245--264.
[15]
Jonathan Cohen, Dana Weimann-Saks, and Maya Mazor-Tregerman. 2018. Does character similarity increase identification and persuasion? Media Psychology, Vol. 21, 3 (2018), 506--528.
[16]
Tom Cole and Marco Gillies. 2021. Thinking and doing: Challenge, agency, and the eudaimonic experience in video games. Games and Culture, Vol. 16, 2 (2021), 187--207.
[17]
Tom Cole and Marco Gillies. 2022. Emotional exploration and the eudaimonic gameplay experience: a grounded theory. In Proceedings of the 2022 CHI Conference on Human Factors in Computing Systems. 1--16.
[18]
Kristina Henry Collins, Erica F Price, Lisa Hanson, and Dianne Neaves. 2020. Consequences of stereotype threat and imposter syndrome: The personal journey from stem-practitioner to stem-educator for four women of color. Taboo: The Journal of Culture and Education, Vol. 19, 4 (2020), 10.
[19]
Catherine Cozzarelli and Brenda Major. 1990. Exploring the validity of the impostor phenomenon. Journal of Social and Clinical Psychology, Vol. 9, 4 (1990), 401--417.
[20]
Christine P Dancey and John Reidy. 2007. Statistics without maths for psychology. Pearson Education.
[21]
Angela DeCandia Vitoria. 2021. Experiential supervision: Healing imposter phenomenon from the inside out. The Clinical Supervisor, Vol. 40, 2 (2021), 200--217.
[22]
Edward L Deci and Richard M Ryan. 2012. Self-determination theory. Handbook of Theories of Social Psychology, Vol. 1, 20 (2012), 416--436.
[23]
Sleepy Duck. 2018. Learn Japanese To Survive! Kanji Combat. [PC Digital Download], USA: RIVER CROW STUDIO.
[24]
Mary Etchison and David M Kleist. 2000. Review of narrative therapy: Research and utility. The Family Journal, Vol. 8, 1 (2000), 61--66.
[25]
Sanne Feenstra, Christopher T Begeny, Michelle K Ryan, Floor A Rink, Janka I Stoker, and Jennifer Jordan. 2020. Contextualizing the impostor 'syndrome'. Frontiers in Psychology, Vol. 11 (2020), 3206.
[26]
Katelyn M Grasse, Max Kreminski, Noah Wardrip-Fruin, Michael Mateas, and Edward F Melcer. 2022. Using self-determination theory to explore enjoyment of educational interactive narrative games: A case study of Academical. Frontiers in Virtual Reality, Vol. 3 (2022), 847120.
[27]
Katelyn M Grasse, Edward F Melcer, Max Kreminski, Nick Junius, James Ryan, and Noah Wardrip-Fruin. 2021. Academical: a choice-based interactive storytelling game for enhancing moral reasoning, knowledge, and attitudes in responsible conduct of research. In Games and Narrative: Theory and Practice. Springer, 173--189.
[28]
Melanie C Green and Timothy C Brock. 2000. The role of transportation in the persuasiveness of public narratives. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, Vol. 79, 5 (2000), 701.
[29]
Melanie C Green and Keenan M Jenkins. 2014. Interactive narratives: Processes and outcomes in user-directed stories. Journal of Communication, Vol. 64, 3 (2014), 479--500.
[30]
Jarrod Haar and Kirsty de Jong. 2022. Imposter phenomenon and employee mental health: what role do organizations play? Personnel Review (2022).
[31]
Jessica Hammer, Alexandra To, Karen Schrier, Sarah Lynne Bowman, and Geoff Kaufman. 2018. Learning and role-playing games. In Role-playing Game Studies. Routledge, 283--299.
[32]
Tina Sweeney Haney, Lorri Birkholz, and Carolyn Rutledge. 2018. A workshop for addressing the impact of the imposter syndrome on clinical nurse specialists. Clinical Nurse Specialist, Vol. 32, 4 (2018), 189--194.
[33]
Gabriela Heslop, Juliana Bonilla-Velez, Erynne A Faucett, and Cristina Cabrera-Muffly. 2023. Understanding and Overcoming the Psychological Barriers to Diversity: Imposter Syndrome and Stereotype Threat. Current Otorhinolaryngology Reports (2023), 1--8.
[34]
Martin R Huecker, Jacob Shreffler, Patrick T McKeny, and David Davis. 2022. Imposter Phenomenon. (2022).
[35]
Bob Jamison. 1973. Lemonade Stand. [Mainframe], USA: Minnesota Educational Computing Consortium.
[36]
Chaima Jemmali and Zijian Yang. 2016. May's Journey: A serious game to teach middle and high school girls programming. Master's thesis. Worcester Polytechnic Institute (2016).
[37]
Geoff F Kaufman and Lisa K Libby. 2012. Changing beliefs and behavior through experience-taking. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, Vol. 103, 1 (2012), 1.
[38]
Greg Kearsley and Ben Shneiderman. 1998. Engagement theory: A framework for technology-based teaching and learning. Educational Technology, Vol. 38, 5 (1998), 20--23.
[39]
Md Nafiul Alam Khan, M Miah, Md Shahjalal, Talha Bin Sarwar, Md Shahariar Rokon, et al. 2022. Predicting young imposter syndrome using ensemble learning. Complexity, Vol. 2022 (2022).
[40]
John Kolligian Jr and Robert J Sternberg. 1991. Perceived fraudulence in young adults: Is there an `imposter syndrome'? Journal of Personality Assessment, Vol. 56, 2 (1991), 308--326.
[41]
Kori A LaDonna, Shiphra Ginsburg, and Christopher Watling. 2018. 'Rising to the level of your incompetence': what physicians? self-assessment of their performance reveals about the imposter syndrome in medicine. Academic Medicine, Vol. 93, 5 (2018), 763--768.
[42]
R Eric Landrum, Karen Brakke, and Maureen A McCarthy. 2019. The pedagogical power of storytelling. Scholarship of Teaching and Learning in Psychology, Vol. 5, 3 (2019), 247.
[43]
Frank Lantz, Bennett Foddy, and Hillary Lantz. 2017. Universal Paperclips. [Web Browser], USA.
[44]
HwaYoung Lee, Cheryl B Anderson, Melinda S Yates, Shine Chang, and Devasmita Chakraverty. 2020. Insights into the complexity of the impostor phenomenon among trainees and professionals in STEM and medicine. Current Psychology (2020), 1--12.
[45]
Matthew Lombard, Theresa B Ditton, and Lisa Weinstein. 2009. Measuring presence: the temple presence inventory. In Proceedings of the 12th Annual International Workshop on Presence. 1--15.
[46]
Matthew Lombard, Lisa Weinstein, and Theresa Ditton. 2011. Measuring telepresence: The validity of the Temple Presence Inventory (TPI) in a gaming context. In ISPR 2011: The International Society for Presence Research Annual Conference. Edinburgh.
[47]
Linbo Luo, Wentong Cai, Suiping Zhou, Michael Lees, and Haiyan Yin. 2015. A review of interactive narrative systems and technologies: a training perspective. Simulation, Vol. 91, 2 (2015), 126--147.
[48]
Karina KL Mak, Sabina Kleitman, and Maree J Abbott. 2019. Impostor phenomenon measurement scales: a systematic review. Frontiers in Psychology, Vol. 10 (2019), 671.
[49]
Rosa Mikeal Martey, Kate Kenski, James Folkestad, Laurie Feldman, Elana Gordis, Adrienne Shaw, Jennifer Stromer-Galley, Ben Clegg, Hui Zhang, Nissim Kaufman, et al. 2014. Measuring game engagement: multiple methods and construct complexity. Simulation & Gaming, Vol. 45, 4--5 (2014), 528--547.
[50]
Peter Mawhorter, Michael Mateas, Arnav Jhala, and Noah Wardrip-Fruin. 2014. Towards a theory of choice poetics. In In Proceedings of the 9th International Conference on the Foundations of Digital Games.
[51]
Peter Mawhorter, Carmen Zegura, Alex Gray, Arnav Jhala, Michael Mateas, and Noah Wardrip-Fruin. 2018. Choice poetics by example. In Arts, Vol. 7. MDPI, 47.
[52]
Kosha J Mehta. 2022. Effect of sleep and mood on academic performance?at interface of physiology, psychology, and education. Humanities and Social Sciences Communications, Vol. 9, 1 (2022), 1--13.
[53]
Edward F Melcer, Katelyn M Grasse, James Ryan, Nick Junius, Max Kreminski, Dietrich Squinkifer, Brent Hill, and Noah Wardrip-Fruin. 2020. Getting Academical: A Choice-Based Interactive Storytelling Game for Teaching Responsible Conduct of Research. In Proceedings of the 15th International Conference on the Foundations of Digital Games-FDG.
[54]
Cynthia J Metz, Erin Ballard, and Michael J Metz. 2020. The stress of success: an online module to help first-year dental students cope with the impostor phenomenon. Journal of Dental Education, Vol. 84, 9 (2020), 1016--1024.
[55]
Lydia Michie, Madeline Balaam, John McCarthy, Timur Osadchiy, and Kellie Morrissey. 2018. From her story, to our story: Digital storytelling as public engagement around abortion rights advocacy in Ireland. In Proceedings of the 2018 CHI Conference on Human Factors in Computing Systems. 1--15.
[56]
Lynn Carol Miller, Paul Robert Appleby, John L Christensen, Carlos Godoy, Mei Si, Charisse Corsbie-Massay, Stephen J Read, Stacy Marsella, Alexandra N Anderson, and Jennifer Klatt. 2012. Virtual interactive interventions for reducing risky sex: adaptations, integrations, and innovations. In eHealth Applications. Routledge, 79--95.
[57]
Tsuzuki Nagai and James York. 2022. A comparison of linear and interactive fiction on vocabulary acquisition, reading comprehension and engagement. Remote Teaching & Beyond (2022), 70.
[58]
Trisha M Nguyen, Mohammed Khadadeh, and David C Jeong. 2023. Shippers and Kinnies: Re-conceptualizing Parasocial Relationships with Fictional Characters in Contemporary Fandom. In Proceedings of the 18th International Conference on the Foundations of Digital Games. 1--12.
[59]
Heather L O'Brien and Elaine G Toms. 2008. What is user engagement? A conceptual framework for defining user engagement with technology. Journal of the American society for Information Science and Technology, Vol. 59, 6 (2008), 938--955.
[60]
Eva Ostertagova, Oskar Ostertag, and Jozef Kovávc. 2014. Methodology and application of the Kruskal-Wallis test. Applied Mechanics and Materials, Vol. 611 (2014), 115--120.
[61]
Anna Parkman. 2016. The imposter phenomenon in higher education: Incidence and impact. Journal of Higher Education Theory & Practice, Vol. 16, 1 (2016).
[62]
Martin P Paulus and J Yu Angela. 2012. Emotion and decision-making: affect-driven belief systems in anxiety and depression. Trends in Cognitive Sciences, Vol. 16, 9 (2012), 476--483.
[63]
Katherine Picho, Ethan Osborne, Fatyma Camacho, Aaja Ouellette, Mason Woodford, and Edward Melcer. 2022. Resilient IN: Design of an Interactive Narrative HRV-Biofeedback Game to Develop Stereotype and Social Identity Threat Resilience. In Joint International Conference on Serious Games. Springer, 84--101.
[64]
Andrew K Przybylski, C Scott Rigby, and Richard M Ryan. 2010. A motivational model of video game engagement. Review of General Psychology, Vol. 14, 2 (2010), 154--166.
[65]
Zoe Quinn, Patrick Lindsey, and Isaac Schankler. 2013. Depression Quest. [Web Browser], USA.
[66]
Jennifer L Ramsey and Abby L Spencer. 2019. Interns and imposter syndrome: proactively addressing resilience. Medical Education, Vol. 53, 5 (2019), 504--505.
[67]
Don Rawitsch, Bill Heinemann, and Paul Dillengerger. 1971. The Oregon Trail. [HP 2100], USA.
[68]
C Scott Rigby and Richard M Ryan. 2016. Time well-spent?: Motivation for entertainment media and its eudaimonic aspects through the lens of self-determination theory. In The Routledge Handbook of Media Use and Well-being. Routledge, 34--48.
[69]
Nancy Rivera, Elana A Feldman, Dimitri A Augustin, Wendy Caceres, Hayley A Gans, and Rebecca Blankenburg. 2021. Do I belong here? Confronting imposter syndrome at an individual, peer, and institutional level in health professionals. MedEdPORTAL, Vol. 17 (2021), 11166.
[70]
Christian Roth and Hartmut Koenitz. 2016. Evaluating the user experience of interactive digital narrative. In Proceedings of the 1st International Workshop on Multimedia Alternate Realities. 31--36.
[71]
Jonathan Rowe, Bradford Mott, Scott McQuiggan, Jennifer Robison, Sunyoung Lee, and James Lester. 2009. Crystal Island: A narrative-centered learning environment for eighth grade microbiology. In Workshop on Intelligent Educational Games at the 14th International Conference on Artificial Intelligence in Education, Brighton, UK. 11--20.
[72]
Richard M Ryan and Edward L Deci. 2017. Self-Determination Theory: Basic psychological needs in motivation, development, and wellness. Guilford Publications.
[73]
Richard M Ryan and Edward L Deci. 2022. Self-determination theory. In Encyclopedia of Quality of Life and Well-being Research. Springer, 1--7.
[74]
Richard M Ryan, C Scott Rigby, and Andrew Przybylski. 2006. The motivational pull of video games: A self-determination theory approach. Motivation and Emotion, Vol. 30 (2006), 344--360.
[75]
Jaruwan Sakulku. 2011. The impostor phenomenon. The Journal of Behavioral Science, Vol. 6, 1 (2011), 75--97.
[76]
Edu Sánchez. 2021. A Blank Page. [Web Browser], USA.
[77]
Tait D Shanafelt, Lotte N Dyrbye, Christine Sinsky, Mickey Trockel, Maryam S Makowski, Michael Tutty, Hanhan Wang, Lindsey E Carlasare, and Colin P West. 2022. Imposter phenomenon in US physicians relative to the US working population. In Mayo Clinic Proceedings, Vol. 97. Elsevier, 1981--1993.
[78]
Mei Si and Stacy C Marsella. 2014. Encoding theory of mind in character design for pedagogical interactive narrative. Advances in Human-Computer Interaction, Vol. 2014 (2014), 10--10.
[79]
Squinky. 2013. Impostor Syndrome. [Web Browser], USA.
[80]
Katryna Starks, Dakoda Barker, and Alayna Cole. 2016. Using Twine as a therapeutic writing tool for creating serious games. In Serious Games: Second Joint International Conference, JCSG 2016, Brisbane, QLD, Australia, September 26--27, 2016, Proceedings 2. Springer, 89--103.
[81]
Sharon T Steinemann, Glena H Iten, Klaus Opwis, Seamus F Forde, Lars Frasseck, and Elisa D Mekler. 2017. Interactive narratives affecting social change. Journal of Media Psychology (2017).
[82]
Sharon T Steinemann, Elisa D Mekler, and Klaus Opwis. 2015. Increasing donating behavior through a game for change: The role of interactivity and appreciation. In Proceedings of the 2015 Annual Symposium on Computer-Human Interaction in Play. 319--329.
[83]
SukeraSparo. 2017. The Expression Amrilato. [PC Digital Download], Japan: mirai works, USA: MangaGamer.
[84]
Mary Thomas and Silvia Bigatti. 2020. Perfectionism, impostor phenomenon, and mental health in medicine: a literature review. International Journal of Medical Education, Vol. 11 (2020), 201.
[85]
Riva Tukachinsky. 2014. Experimental manipulation of psychological involvement with media. Communication Methods and Measures, Vol. 8, 1 (2014), 1--33.
[86]
April Tyack and Elisa D Mekler. 2020. Self-determination theory in HCI games research: Current uses and open questions. In Proceedings of the 2020 CHI Conference on Human Factors in Computing Systems. 1--22.
[87]
April Tyack and Peta Wyeth. 2017. Exploring relatedness in single-player video game play. In Proceedings of the 29th Australian Conference on Computer-Human Interaction. 422--427.
[88]
Tom Van Laer, Ko De Ruyter, Luca M Visconti, and Martin Wetzels. 2014. The extended transportation-imagery model: A meta-analysis of the antecedents and consequences of consumers' narrative transportation. Journal of Consumer Research, Vol. 40, 5 (2014), 797--817.
Index Terms
- Pseudo-Scientist: Towards Narrative Interventions for Imposter Syndrome
Recommendations
Towards the problem of maintaining suspense in interactive narrative
IE '10: Proceedings of the 7th Australasian Conference on Interactive EntertainmentThe paper introduces the problem of creating and maintaining suspense in interactive narrative. We argue that by manipulating choice options offered to the audience in suspenseful scenes in the interactive story both when it is read the first time and ...
Towards a narrative theory of virtual reality
Virtual Reality (VR), by its nature and characteristics, is of specific interest to the AI community, particularly in the domains of Storytelling and Intelligent Characters. We argue that VR must be considered a particular narrative medium alongside ...
Lost cause, an interactive film project
MM '08: Proceedings of the 16th ACM international conference on MultimediaOne of the challenges in designing an interactive cinematic experience is to offer interactive choices, which does not distract the user from immersion into the story. The interactive film Lost Cause focuses on the life of the main character explored ...
Comments
Information & Contributors
Information
Published In
October 2024
1726 pages
Copyright © 2024 Owner/Author.
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution International 4.0 License.
Publisher
Association for Computing Machinery
New York, NY, United States
Publication History
Published: 15 October 2024
Published in PACMHCI Volume 8, Issue CHI PLAY
Check for updates
Author Tags
Qualifiers
- Research-article
Contributors
Other Metrics
Bibliometrics & Citations
Bibliometrics
Article Metrics
- 0Total Citations
- 152Total Downloads
- Downloads (Last 12 months)152
- Downloads (Last 6 weeks)118
Reflects downloads up to 10 Dec 2024
Other Metrics
Citations
View Options
Login options
Check if you have access through your login credentials or your institution to get full access on this article.
Sign in