It has long been postulated that the elongated hindwing tails of many saturniid moths have evolved to create false sonar targets to divert the attack of echolocation-guided bat predators. However, rigorous echo-acoustic evidence to support this hypothesis has been lacking. In this study, fluttering luna moths (Actias luna), a species with elongated hindwing tails, were ensonified with frequency modulated chirp signals from all angles of orientation and across the wingbeat cycle. High-speed stereo videography was combined with pulse compression sonar processing to characterize the echo information available to foraging bats. Contrary to previous suggestions, the results show that the tail echoes are weak and do not dominate the sonar returns, compared to the large, planar wings and the moth body. However, the distinctive twisted morphology of the tails create persistent echoes across all angles of orientation, which may induce erroneous sonar target localization and disrupt accurate tracking by echolocating bats. These findings thus suggest a refinement of the false target hypothesis to emphasize sonar localization errors induced by the twisted tails, and highlight the importance of physics-based approaches to study the sensory information involved in the evolutionary arms race between moths and their bat predators.
REFERENCES
1.
ANSI
(1995
). S1.26-1995 (R2009), Method for Calculation of the Absorption of Sound by the Atmosphere
( Acoustical Society of America
, New York
).2.
3.
Barber
, J. R.
, Leavell
, B. C.
, Keener
, A. L.
, Breinholt
, J. W.
, Chadwell
, B. A.
, McClure
, C. J. W.
, Hill
, G. M.
, and Kawahara
, A. Y.
(2015
). “ Moth tails divert bat attack: Evolution of acoustic deflection
,” Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. U.S.A.
112
, 2812
–2816
.4.
Bates
, M. E.
, Simmons
, J. A.
, and Zorikov
, T. V.
(2011
). “ Bats use echo harmonic structure to distinguish their targets from background clutter
,” Science
333
, 627
–630
.5.
Burkard
, R.
, and Moss
, C. F.
(1994
). “ The brain-stem auditory-evoked response in the big brown bat (Eptesicus fuscus) to clicks and frequency-modulated sweeps
,” J. Acoust. Soc. Am.
96
, 801
–810
.6.
Chu
, D.
, and Stanton
, T. K.
(1998
). “ Application of pulse compression techniques to broadband acoustic scattering by live individual zooplankton
,” J. Acoust. Soc. Am.
104
, 39
–55
.7.
Conover
, W. J.
(1999
). Practical Nonparametric Statistics
, 3rd ed. ( Wiley
, New York
).8.
9.
D'Abrera
, B.
(1998
). Saturniidae Mundi: Saturniid Moths of the World
( Antiquariat Goecke Evers
, Keltern, Germany
).10.
Denzinger
, A.
, and Schnitzler
, H.-U.
(2013
). “ Bat guilds, a concept to classify the highly diverse foraging and echolocation behaviors of microchiropteran bats
,” Front. Physiol.
4
, 164
.11.
Efron
, B.
(1982
). “ The jackknife, the bootstrap, and other resampling plans
,” in CBMS-NSF Regional Conference Series in Applied Mathematics
, Society for Industrial and Applied Mathematics
, Philadelphia, PA
.12.
Emde
, G.
, and Schnitzler
, H.-U.
(1990
). “ Classification of insects by echolocating greater horseshoe bats
,” J. Comp. Physiol. A
167
, 423
–430
.13.
Goerlitz
, H. R.
, Hofstede
, H. M. ter
, Zeale
, M. R. K.
, Jones
, G.
, and Holderied
, M. W.
(2010
). “ An aerial-hawking bat uses stealth echolocation to counter moth hearing
,” Curr. Biol.
20
, 1568
–1572
.14.
Griffin
, D. R.
, Webster
, F. A.
, and Michael
, C. R.
(1960
). “ The echolocation of flying insects by bats
,” Anim. Behav.
8
, 141
–154
.15.
Harris
, F. J.
(1978
). “ On the use of windows for harmonic analysis with the discrete Fourier transform
,” Proc. IEEE
66
, 51
–83
.16.
Hedrick
, T. L.
(2008
). “ Software techniques for two- and three-dimensional kinematic measurements of biological and biomimetic systems
,” Bioinspir. Biomim.
3
, 034001
.17.
Jones
, G.
(1999
). “ Scaling of echolocation call parameters in bats
,” J. Exp. Biol.
202
, 3359
–3367
.18.
Kamoun
, S.
(1991
). “ Parasematic coloration: A novel anti-predator mechanism in tiger beetles (Coleoptera: Cicindelidae)
,” Coleopt. Bull.
45
, 15
–19
.19.
Kjernsmo
, K.
, and Merilaita
, S.
(2013
). “ Eyespots divert attacks by fish
,” Proc. Biol. Sci.
280
, 20131458
.20.
Kober
, R.
, and Schnitzler
, H.-U.
(1990
). “ Information in sonar echoes of fluttering insects available for echolocating bats
,” J. Acoust. Soc. Am.
87
, 882
–896
.21.
Kodandaramaiah
, U.
(2011
). “ The evolutionary significance of butterfly eyespots
,” Behav. Ecol.
22
, 1264
–1271
.22.
Levanon
, N.
, and Mozeson
, E.
(2004
). “ Ambiguity function
,” in Radar Signals
( Wiley
, New York
), pp. 34
–52
.23.
Meadows
, D. W.
(1993
). “ Morphological variation in eyespots of the foureye butterflyfish (Chaetodon capistratus): Implications for eyespot function
,” Copeia
1993
, 235
–240
.24.
Morse
, P. M.
, and Ingard
, K. U.
(1987
). Theoretical Acoustics
( Princeton University Press
, Princeton
).25.
Moss
, C. F.
, Chiu
, C.
, and Surlykke
, A.
(2011
). “ Adaptive vocal behavior drives perception by echolocation in bats
,” Curr. Opin. Neurobiol.
21
, 645
–652
.26.
Moss
, C. F.
, and Schnitzler
, H.-U.
(1995
). “ Behavioral studies of auditory information processing
,” in Hearing by Bats
, Springer Handbook of Auditory Research, edited by
R.
Fay
and
A.
Popper
( Springer-Verlag
, Berlin
), pp. 87
–145
.27.
Moss
, C. F.
, and Surlykke
, A.
(2001
). “ Auditory scene analysis by echolocation in bats
,” J. Acoust. Soc. Am.
110
, 2207
–2226
.28.
Moss
, C. F.
, and Zagaeski
, M.
(1994
). “ Acoustic information available to bats using frequency-modulated sounds for the perception of insect prey
,” J. Acoust. Soc. Am.
95
, 2745
–2756
.29.
Robbins
, R. K.
(1981
). “ The ‘false head’ hypothesis: Predation and wing pattern variation of lycaenid butterflies
,” Am. Nat.
118
, 770
–775
.30.
Roeder
, K. D.
(1963
). “ Echoes of ultrasonic pulses from flying moths
,” Biol. Bull.
124
, 200
–210
.31.
Simmons
, J. A.
(1973
). “ The resolution of target range by echolocating bats
,” J. Acoust. Soc. Am.
54
, 157
–173
.32.
Simmons
, J. A.
, and Chen
, L.
(1989
). “ The acoustic basis for target discrimination by FM echolocating bats
,” J. Acoust. Soc. Am.
86
, 1333
–1350
.33.
Simmons
, J. A.
, Moss
, C. F.
, and Ferragamo
, M.
(1990
). “ Convergence of temporal and spectral information into acoustic images of complex sonar targets perceived by the echolocating bat, Eptesicus fuscus
,” J. Comp. Physiol. A
166
, 449
–470
.34.
Simmons
, J. A.
, and Stein
, R. A.
(1980
). “ Acoustic imaging in bat sonar: Echolocation signals and the evolution of echolocation
,” J. Comp. Physiol. A
135
, 61
–84
.35.
Stanton
, T. K.
, Chu
, D.
, Wiebe
, P. H.
, Martin
, L. V.
, and Eastwood
, R. L.
(1998
). “ Sound scattering by several zooplankton groups. I. Experimental determination of dominant scattering mechanisms
,” J. Acoust. Soc. Am.
103
, 225
–235
.36.
Stevens
, M.
(2005
). “ The role of eyespots as anti-predator mechanisms, principally demonstrated in the Lepidoptera
,” Biol. Rev. Cambridge Philos. Soc.
80
, 573
–588
.37.
Surlykke
, A.
, Filskov
, M.
, Fullard
, J. H.
, and Forrest
, E.
(1999
). “ Auditory relationships to size in noctuid moths: Bigger is better
,” Naturwissenschaften
86
, 238
–241
.41.
38.
Van Buskirk
, J.
, Aschwanden
, J.
, Buckelmüller
, I.
, Reolon
, S.
, and Rüttiman
, S.
(2004
). “ Bold tail coloration protects tadpoles from dragonfly strikes
,” Copeia
2004
, 599
–602
.39.
Waters
, D. A.
, Rydell
, J.
, and Jones
, G.
(1995
). “ Echolocation call design and limits on prey size—A case study using the aerial hawking bat Nyctalus leisleri
,” Behav. Ecol. Sociobiol.
37
, 321
–328
.40.
Weeks
, A.
(1903
). “ Theory as to evolution of secondaries of moths of the genus Catocala
,” J. New York Entomol. Soc.
11
, 221
–226
.© 2016 Acoustical Society of America.
2016
Acoustical Society of America
You do not currently have access to this content.