Abstract
This article examines the rape and suicide of the archetypal Roman matron Lucretia and the representation and appropriation of her story in literature from Augustan Rome, Late Antiquity and the medieval period. Rape and suicide have always been highly evocative, topical and controversial actions for scrutinising the relationship between gender and history, and it is no accident that Rome's first high-profile victim was later drawn upon by writers from 2,000 years of European history to explore issues such as appropriate (and inappropriate) female behaviour, sexuality, guilt, redemption, and the ethics of voluntary death. This article offers a diachronic perspective on the long afterlife of a single Roman myth and the potency of that myth as a privileged and effective point of reference for exploring femininity, rape and suicide in European history.
Similar content being viewed by others
Notes
See, e.g. the “Introduction” in Renzetti and Bergen [74] for a summary of the subjects discussed in that volume.
However, there are some similarities in the topics broached by volumes that study ancient accounts of rape. For example, the Preface in Deacy and Pierce [19] explains that some of the key questions to be considered are the motives of the rapists, and the attachment of blame to the victims by society.
Mardorossian also comments on the lack of discussions of rape in contemporary feminist theory [56, p. 743].
All translations are my own, unless otherwise stated. For the edition used see [55]
Bauman argues that Lucretia would legally have been guilty of committing adultery because she ‘consented’ to the rape, as the element of coercion by violence was only allowed for from the early first century bc onwards [5, p. 552].
See also [2, p. 209].
As noted by [57, p. 37].
See, e.g. [10, p. 168], for the idea that her suicide is neither straightforwardly masculine nor feminine.
See e.g. [24, p. 181].
As Edwards points out [24, p. 183].
This is in contrast to Ovid’s version where he includes details on Lucretia’s experience at this point: see below.
Pudicitia can be seen as a feminine virtue parallel to the masculine virtue won on the battlefield [52, p. 76].
See [44, pp. 165–166].
For the edition used see [67]
As noted by [63, p. 37].
See also [6, pp. 8–9] on the Sabines in the Ars Amatoria.
Richlin comments that ‘the simile of doves and lambs is similarly familiar, and was in fact a commonplace’, evident in Horace also [76, p. 167].
On this, see also [76, p. 172].
See above. Conversely, Livy’s Lucretia is silent in this earlier part of the narrative and then more vocal after the rape.
Knox [48, p. 214], commenting on the form ‘sanguinolenta’ used in Heroides 7; there are only three other known uses of it in classical verse aside from in Ovid, who uses it 15 times.
Richlin comments that Ovid takes care in his narrative to emphasise such physical details [76, p. 172].
As Newlands points out [63, p. 43].
Arieti suggests that this detail is a ‘touch worthy of a Verdi opera’ [2, p. 213].
Richlin notes that Lucretia ‘ends as she began, as object of the gaze’ [76, p. 172].
As Beard has pointed out, ‘Roman men talked rape constantly’ and it was ‘one of its [Roman rape’s] jobs….to debate its own terms and definitions’ [6, p. 10].
For example, in the work of the Roman historian Florus written early second century ad (at 1.1.7.11) [28].
Tertullian uses ‘castitas’ for Lucretia’s chastity, a word found more in religious contexts than ‘pudicitia’, and one denoting a more general purity as well as sexual purity (see [52, p. 30]).
Edwards also comments on Tertullian’s argument ‘from the lesser to the greater’ [24, p. 209].
For the edition used see [42]
See, e.g. [73, pp. 33–34].
Menaut comments that Augustine saw it as his duty to rebut these criticisms [60, p. 323].
For the edition used see [3]
See above.
He saw a ‘human vanity’ in her that he did not look kindly upon [88, p. 62].
On this distinction, see, e.g. [70, pp. 11–12, 16, 32, 120–121].
See [9, pp. 402–408].
Just as Ovid subverted Livy’s Lucretia, although not to the extent of Augustine: see above.
O’Daly argues for the potential of readers from both groups [64, p. 36].
As noted by Amundsen [1, p. 129].
Amundsen [1] provides a solid overview of the topic.
For Ambrose: De Virginibus, 3.7.23-7; for Jerome see above and his Commentary on Jonah, 1.6 (both written late fourth century before Augustine wrote De Civitate Dei).
As Trout argues [88, pp. 67–69].
See [20, p. 117]. This paper also offers some insights into how Augustine viewed the concept of martyrdom.
Kaufman [45, pp. 4–5].
See also [69, p. 262].
As Donaldson notes [21, p. 31].
Although many portrayed her as a figure to be lauded, Augustine’s ideas did have some lasting influence, e.g. Huguccio condemned her for ‘choosing’ to be raped and therefore appearing to be guilty of committing adultery (see [31, p. 814]); Thomas Aquinas also implies that she might be guilty in his Summa Theologiae (at 124.4.2).
For more on these ideas, see [69, Chap. 15].
See above.
See also [36, pp. 107–111].
As Frank suggests [30, p. 105].
Percival suggests that the reader is being invited to empathise with Tarquinius to some extent in the narrative [69, p. 273].
See the glossary on related terms in the Riverside Chaucer (1988, 1302–1303).
Delany does not see the swoon’s inclusion as straightforwardly absolving Lucretia, but identifies a sexual pun in Chaucer’s lines here [18, pp. 145–146].
Kiser describes her as ‘saintly only by the standards of her own pagan culture’ (1983, 106); Galloway suggests that Chaucer sees her decision as ‘valid, that is, in its own historical context of the 'shame culture' of ancient Rome’ [47, p. 827].
For the edition used see [33]
Gower spends much time discussing the evil deeds of Tarquinius and his father (7.4573 onwards).
All the following quotes are from 2.44.1 of Pizan’s City of Ladies [see 71].
See above.
McKinley attests to the increasing number of Ovidian texts in England between 1200 and 1500 in a ‘wide array of types of writing’, and to the deep influence Ovid had on Chaucer and Gower [58, pp. 197–199], and Clark surveys his prominence from Late Antiquity to the Middle Ages [16, pp. 1–25]. Livy, on the other hand, was not brought ‘out of the oblivion into which he had fallen’ until the early fourteenth century, and it seems that the ‘scandalous’ nature of Ovid’s work made him a more popular choice for those reading the classical authors [see the entry for ‘Classics’ in André Vauchez (ed.) Encyclopedia of the Middle Ages (2000)].
Wolfthal also provides evidence for other contemporary views that suicide was the appropriate response to rape [94, p. 61].
As Wolfthal points out [94, p. 67].
See Schibanoff [79] for the likelihood of female literacy and readership at this time.
References
Amundsen, D. W. 1989. Suicide and early Christian values. In Suicide and Euthanasia: Historical and Contemporary Themes, ed. B. A. Brody, 77–153. Kluwer, Dordrecht; London.
Arieti, J. A. 1997. Rape and Livy’s view of Roman history. In Rape in Antiquity, ed. S. Deacy and K. F. Pierce, 209–29. Classical Press of Wales/Duckworth, London
Augustine. 1957. City of God: Volume I, Books I–III. Translated by G. E. McCracken. Loeb Classical Library.
Barnes, T. D. 1971. Tertullian: A Historical and Literary Study. Clarendon, Oxford
Bauman, R. A. 1993. The rape of Lucretia, quod metus causa and the criminal law. Latomus 52: 550–66.
Beard, M. 1999. The erotics of rape: Livy, Ovid and the Sabine women. In Female Networks and the Public Sphere in Roman Society, ed. P. Setälä and L. Savunen, 1–10. Acta Instituti Romani Finlandiae, Rome
Bels, J. 1975. La mort volontaire dans l’oeuvre de saint Augustin’. Revue de l’histoire des religions 187.2: 147–80.
Bowersock, G. W. 1995. Martyrdom and Rome. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge
Brown, P. R. L. 1988. The Body and Society: Men, Women, and Sexual Renunciation in Early Christianity. Columbia University Press, New York, 28th anniversary edition 2008
Calhoon, C. G. 1997. Lucretia, savior and scapegoat: the dynamics of sacrifice in Livy 1.57–59. Helios 24.2: 151–69.
Carlson, M. L. 1948. Pagan examples of fortitude in the Latin Christian apologists. Classical Philology 43.2: 93–104.
Chaucer, Geoffrey. 1987. The Legend of Good Women. Translated by A. McMillan. Rice University Press, Houston
Chaucer, Geoffrey. 1988. The legend of good women. In The Riverside Chaucer, ed. L. G. Benson. Oxford University Press, Oxford.
Clark, E. A. 1991. Sex, shame and rhetoric: en-gendering early Christian ethics. Journal of the American Academy of Religion 59.2: 221–45.
Clark, E. A. 1994. Ideology, history, and the construction of “woman” in late ancient Christianity. Journal of Early Christian Studies 2.2: 155–84.
Clark, J. G. 2011. Introduction. In Ovid in the Middle Ages, ed. J. G. Clark, F. T. Coulson and K. L. McKinley, 1–25. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge
Cowen, J. M. 1985. Chaucer’s Legend of Good Women: structure and tone. Studies in Philology 82.4: 416–36.
Delany, S. 1994. The Naked Text: Chaucer’s Legend of Good Women. University of California Press, Berkeley, London.
Deacy, S. and Pierce, K. F. (ed.) 1997. Rape in Antiquity. Classical Press of Wales/Duckworth, London.
Den Boeft, J. 1989. “Martyres sunt, sed homines fuerunt”: Augustine on Martyrdom. In Fructus Centesimus: Mélanges offerts à Gerard J. M. Bartelink à L’occasion de son Soixante-cinquième Anniversaire, ed. A. A. R. Bastiaensen, A. Hilhorst and C. H. Kneepkens, 115–24. Kluwer, Dordrecht
Donaldson, I. 1982. The Rapes of Lucretia. Oxford University Press, Oxford
Droge, A. J. and Tabor, J. D. 1992. A Noble Death: Suicide and Martyrdom among Christians and Jews in Antiquity. HarperCollins, San Francisco
Dunn, G. D. 2004. Tertullian. Routledge, London; New York.
Edwards, C. 2007. Death in Ancient Rome. Yale University Press, New Haven; London.
Eidinow, E. 2011. Sex, religion, and the law. In A Cultural History of Sexuality, Volume 1: In the Classical World, ed. M. Golden and P. Toohey, 87–106. Berg, Oxford
Fantham, E. 1991. Stuprum: public attitudes and penalties for sexual offences in Republican Rome. Echos du Monde Classique 10: 267–91.
Fenster, T. 1998. “Perdre son latin”: Christine de Pizan and vernacular humanism. In Christine de Pizan and the Categories of Difference, ed. M. Desmond, 91–107. University of Minnesota Press, Minneapolis
Florus. 1929. Epitome of Roman History. Translated by E. S. Forster. Loeb Classical Library.
Fox, M. 1996. Roman historical myths: the regal period in Augustan literature. Oxford University Press, Oxford
Frank, R. W. 1972. Chaucer and the Legend of Good Women. Harvard University Press, Cambridge
Galloway, A. 1993. Chaucer’s legend of Lucrece and the critique of ideology in fourteenth-century England. English Literary History 60.4: 813–32.
Gardner, J. F. 1986. Women in Roman Law and Society. Croom Helm, London
Gower, John. 1980. Confessio Amantis. Ed. R. A. Peck. University of Toronto Press, Toronto
Grig, L. 2004. Making Martyrs in Late Antiquity. Duckworth, London
Hagendahl, H. 1967. Augustine and the Latin Classics: Volume II—Augustine’s Attitude. Almquist and Wiksell, Stockholm
Hallissy, M. 1993. Clean Maids, True Wives, Steadfast Widows: Chaucer’s Women and Medieval Codes of Conduct. Greenwood Press, Westport
Hallissy, M. 1995. A Companion to Chaucer’s Canterbury Tales. Greenwood Press, Westport
Hansen, E. T. 1992. Chaucer and the Fictions of Gender. University of California Press, Berkeley
Hemker, J. 1985. Rape and the founding of Rome. Helios 12: 41–7.
Hillman, R. 1990. Gower’s Lucrece: a new old source for The Rape of Lucrece. Chaucer Review 24.3: 263–70.
Jed, S. H. 1989. Chaste Thinking: The Rape of Lucretia and the Birth of Humanism. Indiana University Press, Bloomington
Jerome. 1883. Adversus Jovinianum. Ed. J.-P. Migne. Patrologia Latina.
Joplin, P. K. 1990. Ritual work on human flesh: Livy’s Lucretia and the rape of the body politic. Helios 17.1: 51–70.
Joshel, S. R. 2002. The body female and the body politic: Livy’s Lucretia and Verginia. In Sexuality and Gender in the Classical World: Readings and Sources, ed. K. McClure, 163–87. Blackwell, Oxford
Kaufman, P. I. 1994. Augustine, martyrs, and misery. Church History 63.1: 1–14.
Kelly, J. N. D. 1975. Jerome: His Life, Writings and Controversies. Duckworth, London
Kiser, L. J. 1983. Telling Classical Tales: Chaucer and the Legend of Good Women. Cornell University Press, Ithaca
Knox, P. E. (ed.) 1995. Ovid Heroides: Select Epistles. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge.
Krawiec, R. 2008. Asceticism. In The Oxford Handbook of Early Christian Studies, ed. S. A. Harvey and D. G. Hunter, 764–85. Oxford University Press, Oxford
Lahnait, F. 2008. Female suicide bombers: victims or murderers? In Suicide Bombers: the Psychological, Religious and Other Imperatives, ed. M. Sharpe, 71–82. IOS Press, Amsterdam
Laird, J. 1995. Good women and bonnes dames: virtuous females in Chaucer and Christine de Pizan. Chaucer Review 30.1: 58–70.
Langlands, R. 2006. Sexual Morality in Ancient Rome. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge
Lape, S. 2011. Heterosexuality. In A Cultural History of Sexuality, Volume 1: In the Classical World, ed. M. Golden and P. Toohey, 17–36. Berg, Oxford
Lee, A. G. 1953. Ovid’s “Lucretia”. Greece and Rome 22: 107–18.
Livy. 1919. History of Rome, Volume I: Books I–II. Translated by B. O. Foster. Loeb Classical Library.
Mardorossian, C. M. 2002. Toward a new feminist theory of rape. Signs 27.3: 743–75.
Matthes, M. M. 2000. The Rape of Lucretia and the Founding of Republics. Pennsylvania State University Press, University Park
McKinley, K. L. 2011. Gower and Chaucer: readings of Ovid in late medieval England. In Ovid in the Middle Ages, ed. J. G. Clark, F. T. Coulson and K. L. McKinley, 197–230. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge
McMillan, A. (ed.) 1987. Geoffrey Chaucer: The Legend of Good Women. Rice University Press, Houston
Menaut, L. 1987. Saint Augustin et le suicide des vierges consacrées. Bulletin de Literature Ecclésiastique 88: 323–8.
Milnor, K. 2005. Gender, Domesticity, and the Age of Augustus: Inventing Private Life. Oxford University Press, Oxford
Minnis, A. J. 1982. Chaucer and Pagan Authority. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge
Newlands, C. W. 1988. The rape of Lucretia in Ovid’s Fasti. Augustan Age 8: 36–48.
O’Daly, G. J. P. 1999. Augustine’s City of God: a Reader’s Guide. Clarendon, Oxford
Ogilvie, R. M. 1965. A commentary on Livy: books 1–5. Clarendon, Oxford
Osborn, E. 1997. Tertullian, first theologian of the West. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge
Ovid. 1989. Fasti. Translated by J. G. Frazer. Loeb Classical Library 2nd revised edition.
Pearsall, D. 1966. Gower’s narrative art. Publications of the Modern Language Association of America 81.7: 475–84.
Percival, F. 1998. Chaucer’s Legendary Good Women. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge
Perkins, J. 1995. The Suffering Self: Pain and Narrative Representation in the Early Christian Era. Routledge, London
Pizan, Christine de. 1982. The Book of the City of Ladies. Translated by E. J. Richards. Persea Books.
Quilligan, M. 1991. The Allegory of Female Authority: Christine de Pizan’s Cité Des Dames. Cornell University Press, Ithaca
Rebenich, S. 2002. Jerome. Routledge, London; New York.
Renzetti, C. M. and Bergen, R. K. (ed.) 2005. Violence Against Women. Rowman & Littlefield, Lanham; Oxford.
Richards, E. J. 1982. Introduction. In Christine de Pizan: The Book of the City of Ladies, xix–li. Persea, New York.
Richlin, A. 1992. Reading Ovid’s rapes. In Pornography and Representation in Greece and Rome, ed. A. Richlin, 158–79. Oxford University Press, New York; Oxford.
Robertson, E. and Rose, C. M. 2001. Introduction. In Representing Rape in Medieval and Early Modern Literature, ed. E. Robertson and C. M. Rose, 1–17. Palgrave, New York
Rose, C. M. 2001. Reading Chaucer reading rape. In Representing Rape in Medieval and Early Modern Literature, ed. E. Robertson and C. M. Rose, 21–60. Palgrave, New York
Schibanoff, S. 1994. “Taking the gold out of Egypt”: the art of reading as a woman. In Feminist Readings in Middle English Literature: The Wife of Bath and all her sect, ed. R. Evans and L. Johnson, 221–45. Routledge, London
Skaine, R. 2006. Female Suicide Bombers. Cedar Falls
Skinner, M. 1987. Introduction. In Rescuing Creusa: New Methodological Approaches to Women in Antiquity, ed. M. Skinner, 1–8. Texas Tech University Press, Lubbock
Skinner, M. B. 2005. Sexuality in Greek and Roman Culture. Blackwell, Oxford
Treggiari, S. 1991. Roman Marriage: Iusti Coniuges from the Time of Cicero to the Time of Ulpian. Clarendon, Oxford
Sylvester, L. 2000. Reading narratives of rape: the story of Lucretia in Chaucer, Gower and Christine de Pizan. Leeds Studies in English 31: 115–44.
Tertullian. 1878–9. Ad Martyres. Ed. J.-P. Migne. Patrologia Latina.
Tertullian. 1878–9. De Exhortatione Castitatis. Ed. J.-P. Migne. Patrologia Latina.
Tertullian. 1878–9. De Monogamia. Ed. J.-P. Migne. Patrologia Latina.
Trout, D. 1994. Re-textualising Lucretia: cultural subversion in the City of God. Journal of Early Christian Studies 2.1: 53–70.
Van der Horst, P. W. 1971. A pagan Platonist and a Christian Platonist on suicide. Vigiliae Christianae 25.4: 282–8.
Vandiver, E. 1999. The founding mothers of Livy’s Rome: the Sabine women and Lucretia. In The Eye Expanded: Life and the Arts in Greco-Roman antiquity, ed. F. B. Titchener and R. F. Moorton, 206–32. University of California Press, Berkeley
Van Hooff, A. J. L. 1990. From Autothanasia to Suicide: Self-Killing in Classical Antiquity. Routledge, London; New York.
Victor, B. 2004. Army of Roses: Inside the World of Palestinian Women Suicide Bombers. Robinson, London.
Wyke, M. 2002. The Roman Mistress: Ancient and Modern Representations. Oxford University Press, Oxford.
Wolfthal, D. 1998. “Douleur sur toutes autres”: Revisualizing the rape script in the Epistre Othea and the Cité des dames. In Christine de Pizan and the Categories of Difference, ed. M. Desmond, 41–70. University of Minnesota Press, Minneapolis
Wolfthal, D. 1999. Images of Rape: the ‘Heroic’ Tradition and its Alternatives. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge.
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Glendinning, E. Reinventing Lucretia: Rape, Suicide and Redemption from Classical Antiquity to the Medieval Era. Int class trad 20, 61–82 (2013). https://doi.org/10.1007/s12138-013-0322-y
Published:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s12138-013-0322-y