The ZIMBABWE Situation | Our
thoughts and prayers are with Zimbabwe - may peace, truth and justice prevail. |
"The international community
now refers to emerging Asian countries as
well and does not only include the
Western countries. The Chinese are happy
with Zimbabwe and they are willing
to support this country," said
Mumbengegwi, seemingly oblivious of the fact
that the look-east policy
adopted by the government a couple of years ago
has, at most, brought mixed
results and at worst, nothing.
Mumbengegwi’s statement underlines the extent to which government
ministers
are so out of tune at a time when they should be singing from the
same song
sheet. It comes within a week of calls by Finance and Economic
Development
Minister Herbert Murerwa to engage the IMF and the World Bank,
which slammed
the door on the country in 1995 after their patience ran thin
over Zimbabwe’s
stop-go implementation of the failed economic reform
programme.
Two senior World Bank officials on the continent visited Harare last
week and
held consultative meetings with government officials, including
Murerwa, as
well as captains of industry and commerce.
John Nkomo, the Minister
of Special Affairs in the President’s Office,
also told the National Economic
Consultative Forum meeting in Harare
recently that Zimbabwe needed to
re-engage the Bretton Woods institutions.
"Zimbabwe’s sovereignty
is not for bargaining, but we are ready to
engage in mutually beneficial
relations with the outside world in the
capacity of a free and sovereign
nation, governed by its laws and national
constitution," Nkomo
said.
The Finance Ministry permanent secretary, Nick Ncube, among
other
senior government officials, also attended the meeting addressed
by
Mumbengegwi.
The IMF withdrew crucial balance-of-payments
support in 1999, citing
economic mismanagement and other governance
issues.
Major donors, taking their cue from the Bretton Woods
institutions,
have also cut off aid to Zimbabwe.
China, with the
world’s largest population of 1.3 billion, is one of
the world’s fastest
growing economies and is expected to outstrip Germany
and Britain in growth
in the coming years.
Chris Mutsvangwa, Zimbabwe’s Ambassador to
China, aided Mumbengegwi’s
assault, saying the West, including the United
Kingdom and the United
States, were essentially interested in exploiting
Zimbabwe and not
developing it.
"Any trade relations with the
West are not the same as those with the
East. The West has a colonial
mentality of exploitation. Relationships that
started with rape are very
difficult to turn into a happy marriage whereas
with China the business
relationship will be complementary," said
Mutsvangwa.
"China has
more than US$400 billion in foreign currency reserves,
which represent the
second highest in the world after the United States and
Zimbabwe can receive
foreign direct investments from China if it works
closely with that
country."
Observers, however, said government should have an
organised and
agreed line which every minister should toe.
"We
should have a government position that is consistent because
whatever
ministers say affects trade and it affects economic growth and
investment
into the country," said Jonathan Kadzura, an economic comentator.
"The government should also learn to engage the whole world, not just
a
section of the world. The international community also wants to buy
our
products and there is no way we can engage one section while ignoring
the
other," Kadzura said.
FinGaz
ZANU PF in desperate self renewal
Brian
Mangwende
11/21/2003 9:09:35 AM (GMT +2)
THE Masvingo
provincial ZANU PF election sprung a surprise by
catapulting two prominent
tycoons, Mutumwa Mawere and Daniel Shumba, into
the leadership structures,
giving a cue of the party’s long mooted plans to
inject new blood meant to
bolster his faltering fortunes.
The old guard lumbered off the
provincial political stage to pave way
for what is widely perceived as new
and young blood in Masvingo, the home
province of the late Vice-President
Simon Muzenda.
Shumba, the TeleAccess boss, and Mawere, who
presides over an empire
with vast interests across every sector of the
economy and is widely
believed to be Parliamentary Speaker Emmerson
Mnangagwa’s protégé, were
elected to the province’s key positions as
provincial chairman and secretary
for economic affairs,
respectively.
Shumba took over from Samuel Mbengegwi while business
mogul Mawere’s
position was new. Mawere was elected in absentia. Mbengegwi
did not seek
re-election.
Analysts this week said the election
of businessmen into the party
structures in Manicaland, Mashonaland West and
Masvingo could have been
prompted by the need to revive the ailing economy as
they stood to lose out
more, with no solution in sight from the old
guard.
Zimbabwe, ostracised by the international community on
allegations
that President Robert Mugabe stole the March 2002 presidential
election, is
going through it’s worst ever economic crisis in
history.
However, the analysts said they wondered how the
businessmen would
manage the political heat in the country, which could force
them to devote
half their time in the provinces away from their lavish
offices in and out
of the country.
Constitutional law expert and
political analyst, Dr Lovemore Madhuku
said: "This is part of ZANU PF’s
strategy to renew the party. By bringing in
new faces, especially those in
the business sector, ZANU PF can claim that
they are committed to the revival
of the economy. It’s not a bad development
in that it brings into the ZANU PF
leadership people who stand to lose from
a continuous economic
crisis."
Another political analyst, Heneri Dzinotyiwei, who
lectures at the
University of Zimbabwe, said the move was meant to bring in
people with
financial muscle and different thinking. But, he said, it was not
an
entirely new trend.
"I guess the trend is not entirely new,"
said Dzinotyiwei. "But what
could be conspicuous is what is in it for them at
the end of the day. These
are businesspeople with national profiles, why then
should they opt to act
at provincial levels?"
Dzinotyiwei added:
"Anyway, in this case I believe finance, to the
party, is the primary issue
regardless of whether they were active at cell,
branch or district levels.
And generally people are at the stage of
frustration and desperation and they
would see these businesspeople as their
salvation because they have the money
to throw around."
Asked if the election of the two businessmen had
not scuppered party
structures in that they had not first emerged from party
cells going up,
Dzinotyiwei said: "Even Information Minister Jonathan Moyo
shot to the
politburo from nowhere. I guess it’s a special facility by the
ruling party
that space becomes available depending on what you have to offer
and in this
case, the businessmen have the money."
Insiders
within ZANU PF said it was quite normal that those with some
war credentials
or other outstanding service to the country or party could
be catapulted into
the ruling party’s leadership without first having held
office at the lowest
levels.
"That is pretty normal in ZANU PF," a party insider said.
"As a matter
of fact, we welcome the injection of new blood in the provinces.
At least we
are now moving away from the notion that only the bigwigs who
have nothing
new to offer continue to hold office indefinitely. Those
provinces, which
are still to hold elections, should take a cue from Masvingo
and do the
same. We need new thinking in the party to save our nation and at
the same
time uphold the values of our liberation struggle."
In
Mashonaland West, prominent Harare businessman, Philip Chiyangwa,
retained
his seat as provincial chairman while in Manicaland, Mark Madiro
was
re-elected provincial party chairman, shrugging off Charles Pemhenai,
the
province’s secretary for information and publicity.
Most of the old
guard in Manicaland retained their positions while
there were some changes in
Mashonaland West.
FinGaz
Zim issue widens rift in C’wealth
Dumisani
Ndlela Editor and Brian Mangwende
11/21/2003 9:49:25 AM (GMT
+2)
THE issue of Zimbabwe’s invitation to the Commonwealth Heads
of
Government Meeting (CHOGM) in Abuja looked set to widen the split within
the
Commonwealth grouping, with sources indicating that Nigerian
President
Olusegun Obasanjo was under pressure from African colleagues to
send an
invitation to President Robert Mugabe.
President
Obasanjo was in Zimbabwe this week and held discussions with
President Mugabe
and opposition Movement for Democratic Change (MDC) leader
Morgan Tsvangirai
in what MDC insiders said was a plot to push his
colleagues’ plan for
President Mugabe’s inclusion at the CHOGM to be hosted
by Nigeria next
month.
"Even the president (Morgan Tsvangirai) was not clear about
the agenda
of Obasanjo’s visit to Zimbabwe. We have a feeling that he is
trying to push
an agenda for Mugabe’s inclusion at CHOGM by displaying a
modicum of
generosity through his visit to Zimbabwe," the MDC insider
said.
"He wants to create an impression that he is concerned, was
on the
ground and that there is progress in finding a solution to the
country’s
crisis between the MDC and the ruling party," the MDC insider
said.
Tsvangirai sounded unenthusiastic about President Obasanjo’s
visit
when contacted by The Financial Gazette this week.
"He
(Obasanjo) should tell you what he came here for and what he
achieved,"
Tsvangirai said. "It’s not for me to say anything (about
his
visit)."
Giving a cue on Presidents Mugabe and Obasanjo’s
discussions during
the Nigerian head of state’s visit, Foreign Affairs
Minister Stan Mudenge
said in a ministerial statement to parliament that
Zimbabwe was entitled to
go to Abuja for the CHOGM.
"It is now
up to the member states to rally behind Nigeria so as to
make it possible for
the country to live up to its duties and obligations as
the CHOGM host to
invite all members entitled by the rules to attend, and
that includes
Zimbabwe," Mudenge said.
Zimbabwe was suspended from the
Commonwealth grouping of mainly former
British colonies in March 2002 for a
period of 12 months on allegations that
President Mugabe had stolen the poll
from MDC leader Tsvangirai during the
2002 Presidential
election.
Mugabe’s government was also accused of human rights
abuses and the
breakdown in the rule of law and was ordered to restore these
and fulfill
three other benchmark requirements before being re-admitted into
the
grouping.
The government of Zimbabwe must first achieve
national reconciliation
and dialogue before being re-admitted.
President Obasanjo’s visit to Zimbabwe, which critics said was
evidently
designed to create an impression that things where moving in
Zimbabwe in
terms of dialogue between the ruling ZANU PF and the MDC, has
already created
discomfort among opponents of Zimbabwe’s re-admission, who
say there is still
a flagrant disregard of the rule of law, human rights
abuses and the
harassment of civil society and opposition party members.
The
British Foreign Office Minister, Chris Mullin, this week told a
highly
charged parliament that the suspension of Zimbabwe would remain in
place and
would be discussed at the Abuja meeting.
"I am very sorry to say
that there has been little progress towards
meeting any of those benchmarks
or the Commonwealth’s Harare principles for
good governance. There has been
no formal dialogue between the ruling party
and the opposition . . . attacks
on the opposition, independent media and
civil society continue . . . we see
no justification for re-admitting
Zimbabwe to the Commonwealth," Mullin
said.
There have been muted suggestion in Australia that Prime
Minister John
Howard, a vigorous opponent to Zimbabwe’s re-admission, might
boycott CHOGM
if President Mugabe is invited.
Howard forms part
of the troika including President Obasanjo and South
African President Thabo
Mbeki that was tasked with assessing Zimbabwe’s
compliance with Commonwealth
benchmark requirements before being readmitted.
FinGaz
Why Banana’s wife was not at burial
Brian
Mangwende
11/21/2003 9:05:04 AM (GMT +2)
AN irretrievably
broken marriage and possibly asylum conditions
granted to former first lady
Janet Banana by the British government made it
impossible for her to come
back home and attend her late husband, Zimbabwe’s
first President, Reverend
Canaan Banana’s burial.The marriage hit the rocks
as far back as 1987 when
one of the late reverend’s bodyguards revealed to
Janet that her husband was
gay. Prior to this, rumours had swirled about the
country’s first president’s
homosexuality although none of his victims had
come forward to publicly say
so.
The marital problems within the then first couple were
however
compounded by a conviction against Banana in 1998 by the High Court
on 11
counts of sexual assault, including two counts of sodomy, committed
while he
was still in office between 1980 and 1987. His victim, Jefta Dube,
has since
died.
Janet then fled to the UK in October 2000,
together with her then
18-year-old daughter, reportedly with one suitcase and
only £40 on the
advice of family friends in London.
At that time
Janet, who sources say had increasingly become estranged
from her husband,
claimed political persecution after her husband had fallen
out of favour with
his former colleagues in government. She also hinted that
her family had
become social outcasts, stigmatised as "the gay family". It
is however widely
believed that it is the differences with her husband that
led Janet to flee
the country.
Prisilla Misihairabwi-Mushonga, Banana’s niece, told
The Financial
Gazette this week that the Banana family back home was unaware
of the
reasons why Janet had failed to accompany her husband’s body from the
UK
where he had gone to seek medical treatment.
Banana and his
wife were not divorced although they were reportedly on
separation following
the rift caused by Banana’s sexual orientation.
"We don’t know why
she did not come but we’ll talk about that after we
’ve buried my uncle
peacefully," said Misihairabwi-Mushonga, an opposition
Movement for
Democratic Change (MDC) party Member of Parliament for
Glen
Norah.
A gallant fighter for Zimbabwe’s liberation
struggle, Banana was laid
to rest at his rural home in Esigodini on Wednesday
after he was denied
national hero’s status because of his
homosexuality.
President Robert Mugabe has lambasted homosexuals as
"sexual
perverts", describing them as "worse than pigs and
dogs".
Instead, Banana was accorded the status of a state hero,
entitling him
only to a state-assisted funeral befitting a former head of
state.
The status was accorded to him following acrimonious debate
by the
ruling party’s supreme decision-making organ, the Politburo, over
national
hero’s status.
"The Politburo first spoke about his
contribution to the liberation
struggle and his role in uniting ZANU PF and
PF ZAPU after independence," a
party source said. "They paid tribute to him
for all that he did for the
benefit of the nation. Then the issue of his
morality came in with the
majority of the executive saying that it would be
taboo to bury him at the
national shrine because of his sexual behaviour
which led to his
incarceration."
The source, who is privy to the
deliberations, added: "The people from
Matabeleland in the Politburo were
outraged by the final decision to grant
him even a state-assisted funeral.
Some said because of his sexual
behaviour, ZANU PF should have left
everything in the hands of the Banana
family."
The Financial
Gazette has it on good authority that Sikhanyiso Ndhlovu
was the only
Politburo member to vote that Banana be conferred with the
national hero
status. But the rest of the members were unanimous that he be
accorded a
state funeral in his home town in Esigodini with full
military
honours.
In an earlier interview with The Financial
Gazette, ZANU PF national
spokesman Nathan Shamuyarira had said that it was
obvious that Banana would
be declared a national hero because of his
contribution to the liberation
struggle and the role he played in brokering
the Unity Accord in 1987
between the then warring parties, ZANU PF and PF
ZAPU, then led by the late
vice-president Joshua Nkomo.
FinGaz
Zimpost workers strike . . . for 5th time
Zhean
Gwaze
11/21/2003 9:05:54 AM (GMT +2)
WORKERS at Zimpost on
Monday went on strike for the fifth time this
year, disrupting essential
telecommunication services countrywide.
The workers are complaining
that Zimpost management is failing to
comply with a High Court order issued
in 2001 which stated that there should
be no variation in terms of salaries
on all workers from the disbanded Posts
and Telecommunications Corporation
(PTC).
The workers are also demanding that management review their
salaries
on a quarterly basis to cushion them from the highly
inflationary
environment.
The PTC was broken down into TelOne,
Zimpost and NetOne following its
privatisation in 2000.
Communications and Allied Workers’ Union of Zimbabwe secretary-general
Gift
Chimanikire confirmed that the workers had gone on strike demanding
better
conditions of service.
"All other disbanded PTC organs are
following the median quota as
ordered by the High Court in 2001 but Zimpost
management have since moved
away from this. We are demanding that management
increase the salaries to a
minimum net of $200 000 per month," he
said.
The workers’ representatives are said to have met with
management and
Ministry of Labour officials last week to resolve the impasse
but there was
no breakthrough.
Zimpost management is said to be
insisting that it has no mandate from
the board to award the increments to
workers while workers have insisted on
downing tools to press for their
demands.
Efforts to speak to Zimpost management were fruitless as
they were
said to be engaged in marathon meetings.
"Meanwhile,
we will keep any post office across the country closed,"
Chimanikire
said.
FinGaz
MDC set to hold its national conference 14 months
late
Dumisani Ndlela
11/21/2003 9:08:37 AM (GMT
+2)
THE opposition Movement for Democratic Change (MDC) is expected
to
hold its national conference in February next year, 14 months after
failing
to hold one in December last year.
Whereas the
ruling ZANU PF party’s annual conference in December this
year is expected to
be dominated by the issue of succession, particularly
the replacement of the
late Vice-President Simon Muzenda, the MDC leadership
will steer their
conference into debating the decline in the national
economy, the health
delivery system and restoration of the rule of law.
Paul
Themba-Nyathi, the MDC national spokesman, said although December
was one of
the months tentatively pencilled for the conference, "the likely
date will be
in February".
He said the party had failed to hold its annual
conference last year
because of "concrete activities" like mass actions to
protest the
deteriorating economic situation and the outcome of the 2002
Presidential
election controversially won by President Robert
Mugabe.
"Party members would be briefed at the annual conference on
progress
in planned talks with the ruling ZANU PF party and would be
requested to
adopt new ‘policy positions’," Nyathi said, without being
specific.
"Obviously, we will do some soul-searching. We’ll review
why we did
not retain the Insiza seat, even though we know the dice was
loaded against
us," Nyathi, said.
However, he said, there would
be no blame-game at the conference and
the expectation was that "no heads
would roll".
"We don’t want to be weakening the party, but we want
to strengthen
it. I believe we work as a team and no one should be blamed for
any negative
developments during the year," Nyathi said.
Nyathi
said the challenge for the MDC leadership was to convince
members that the
prospect of regime change was close to being achieved, as
pressure was
building up against ZANU PF both from within and outside the
country because
of the deepening economic crisis.
"There is a saying that before
day breaks, its gets darker. This is
the message we will try to put across to
our members in the face of an
intensifying economic crisis," said
Nyathi.
The MDC has been waging a fierce battle against President
Mugabe’s
government, which it accuses of running down the country into its
present
crisis characterised by food, fuel and foreign currency
shortages.
The MDC also accuses President Mugabe of having stolen
its leader
Morgan Tsvangirai’s victory in the 2002 Presidential election, in
which the
ZANU PF leader won by over 400 000 votes.
The MDC
alleges the poll was rigged, voters intimidated and its
candidate denied the
platform to campaign.
FinGaz
Comment
Chigwedere must go
11/21/2003 9:41:10 AM (GMT +2)
THE adage, it never rains but pours,
holds true for Zimbabwe. There
has, for some time now, been general
disillusionment among Zimbabweans
frustrated by deprivation as the economy
precariously sits on shifting
sands.
As if the economic blizzard
is not enough, another deep well of
disenchantment has since cratered. This
time on the educational front, which
is going through a deep-seated crisis as
2003 proves to be a low point for
the country’s increasingly discredited
secondary school examination system.
There has been unprecedented confusion
with students reportedly studying
wrong set books, while others are said to
have received results of subjects
they did not sit for. Sometimes examination
papers are known to have been
leaked and worse still, results of these
examinations are unnecessarily
delayed. The most frightening reality is that,
what has so far emerged
publicly concerning the examinations debacle could
just be but the
proverbial tip of the iceberg. The bigger picture could, for
all we know, be
pretty bad. And the mind boggles as to how this can possibly
happen. Is this
the best we can do? If so, then God help us!
Nothing can be more telling or conclusively prove the ineptitude of
those
running our education system than this bungling. And we can only
imagine how
frustrating this can be to the multitude of affected pupils in
the face of a
sorry tale of unrealised ambitions by scores of other
school-leavers who have
since been condemned to permanent unemployment!
What about the
hard-pressed peasant parents practising the
back-breaking subsistence
agriculture just to afford their children what
they consider a life-time meal
ticket — education? Indeed this is a shining
example of the terrifying swift
decline in standards in this very important
sector, at one time touted as the
best in Africa, hence the need to restore
integrity and credibility into the
education system. The shaken public
confidence in the local examination
system, which is administered by the
much-maligned Zimbabwe Schools
Examinations Council (ZIMSEC), seems to give
credence to claims that Zimbabwe
made a tactical mistake when it switched
from the internationally-acclaimed
Cambridge examinations and localised the
Ordinary and Advanced Level
examinations. With the latest developments,
which represent a problem
situation, calls for "back to Cambridge" could
only justifiably intensify
because this is an issue of legitimate public
concern that is crying out for
urgent attention.
But having said that, we sincerely hope that we
are not going to see
the appointment of yet another fact-finding team,
commission of inquiry or
committee to look into the problems bedevilling the
country’s examinations
system. We have already had enough of these
committees, which are in
themselves emblematic of everything wrong with the
way the government runs
the country’s affairs. In any case, previous such
commissions have been
nothing more than a sheer waste of time and
resources.
It is now time to act to correct something that could
turn out to be a
mistake of historic proportions. Much as a lot of Cabinet
ministers have,
over the years, gotten away with incompetence,
under-performance and
downright ineptitude because of what government calls
collective
responsibility, the mess in the examination system should be
placed squarely
on the shoulders of the Ministry of Education, which seems to
be in serious
need of a crash course in learning how to loosen up without
necessarily
losing control.
Those running our education system
have been on notice to perform but
they have failed the nation dismally. Yet
they don’t seem to care, maybe
because their children get educated outside
the country as they have access
to hard cash even in the face of the biting
forex crunch. Heads must
therefore roll. And since a fish rots from the head,
the axe should fall on
the head of the ministry first — Minister Aeneas
Chigwedere, once a great
teacher but now seemingly out of his depth.
FinGaz
MDC breathes fire over 2004 Budget
11/21/2003 7:53:04 AM (GMT +2)
THE Movement for Democratic Change
(MDC) yesterday took a swipe at the
government, accusing it of failing to
address national issues in the 2004
National Budget presented by Finance
Minister Herbert Murerwa yesterday.
MDC’s secretary for Economic
Affairs, Tendai Biti, said apart from
inadequately addressing the issues at
stake such as runaway inflation, the
exchange rate and negative interest
rates, the budget was "populist and
laced with dishonesty and
hypocrisy".
"The severity of the crisis is such that there was some
hope of new
ideas," Biti, the legislator for Harare East said.
"But sadly, the budget statement provides no evidence of any sort of
change
on the government side.
"On the pivotal macro-economic management
issues in the current
crisis, the budget statement failed to make clear any
position.
"Decisions on these crucial areas are (handed over to)
the Reserve
Bank Governor’s monetary policy statement which is promised by
mid
December."
FinGaz
Move to tap forex from locals living in
Diaspora
11/21/2003 7:54:09 AM (GMT +2)
THE
government, confronted by shrinking foreign currency receipts and
a dollar
that is falling off the cliff, yesterday announced that it has
finalised
plans to mobilise funds from non-resident Zimbabweans.
Finance
Minister Herbert Murerwa said an announcement would soon be
made by the
Reserve Bank of Zimbabwe (RBZ) on how the latest scheme to
bolster the
country’s drying foreign currency coffers would be run.
"Government, through
the central bank, has put in place institutional
structures and
implementation modalities to mobilise foreign currency from
non-resident
Zimbabweans through the formal financial system.
"Plans for its
implementation are at an advanced stage and will be
disclosed in the
governor’s statement," Murerwa said.
This is not the first time
that the government has mooted plans to tap
funds from the Zimbabwean
population in the diaspora. Analysts have
expressed scepticism at the
applicability of the proposal. It still remains
unclear whether the
government would adjust the exchange rate to make it
worthwhile for
Zimbabweans in the diaspora to channel their funds into the
official
market.
The government has stuck to a pegged exchange rate policy
since 1998
and the rate is currently $824 to the greenback, while the
thriving parallel
market quotes the local currency at $6000 to US$1. The
government was
expected to further devalue the local currency, in line with
an undertaking
made to the business community in February, but has been
recalcitrant on the
matter ever since the devaluation at the beginning of the
year.
With much of the hard currency readily available on the
informal
market, the RBZ is currently reporting average inflows of less than
US$5
million monthly. The massive brain drain caused by high levels
of
unemployment, coupled with rapid economic decline, has seen hundreds
of
locals going to seek employment in the United Kingdom, the United States
and
neighbouring South Africa, among other countries.
The
non-resident population remits substantial amounts of hard
currency back
home, largely through unofficial channels.
FinGaz
ZANU PF’s private cemetery
11/21/2003
9:43:51 AM (GMT +2)
EDITOR — It took the ZANU PF government a cool
two weeks to decide
what honour they should bestow on the late Reverend
Canaan Banana.
His crime — the sodomy conviction in the 1990s. But
the vexing
question is, if it is "a matter of principle" how many of the
so-called
heroes buried at the shrine killed, maimed, raped and committed
other
heinous crimes in the name of ZANU PF and the government, were
declared
national heroes?
The truth is the grey-haired men in
the ZANU PF politburo are abusing
everyone in this country, are vindictive,
won’t forgive and like the Mafia,
will mercilessly follow a declared enemy of
ZANU PF even to the grave. They
have even privatised national institutions
like the Heroes Acre.
One day "as a matter of principle" the people
of this country will
have the chance to judge who is a hero and not in ZANU
PF.
Frank Matandirotya,
Chivhu.
FinGaz
Free and fair polls or polls without
democracy?
11/21/2003 9:40:16 AM (GMT +2)
AS we
approach the 2005 parliamentary election, there is still
enormous hope for
our country, which has been teetering on the verge of
complete collapse for
some time now.
But the question is, is Zimbabwe a democracy?
Few conceptual issues in
political science have been subjected to closer or
more prolific scrutiny in
recent years than this problem of "what democracy
is — and is not".
The idea of democracy has become so closely
identified with elections
that we are in danger of forgetting that the modern
history of
representative election is as much a tale of authoritarian
manipulations by
the Zimbabwean regime as it is a saga of democratic triumphs
for the
opposition and civil society.
In the first half of the
year 2000, great political changes swept
across Zimbabwe. Opposition
candidates began to consistently win legislative
seats. These unexpected
changes raised hopes that our country, long known
for political failure, was
about to turn a corner.
But in Zimbabwe, electoral politics have
proven disappointing as
corruption, abuse of power and economic crises
continue to plague the
nation. There is little vertical accountability
despite the regular
elections. Electoral fraud is common and violence against
the opposition
goes unpunished. Civil society and the press are repressed,
further
insulating the government from public scrutiny. Democracy however
requires
not only free, fair and competitive elections, but also the freedoms
that
make them truly meaningful such as freedom of expression,
alternative
sources of information and institutions to ensure that "winners"
depend on
the vote and preference of citizens.
But vexing
questions remain. What constitutes a "fair, honest and free
election"? How
can we know that parties have had a fair chance to campaign
and that voters
around the country have been enabled to exercise their will
freely? How can
we know that the reported results accurately reflect the
votes that were
cast?
First, the ZANU PF regime, cornered, scared and frightened
than
before, conducts regular multi-party elections but fails to meet
the
substantive test or does so only ambiguously. Secondly, with
heightened
international expectations and standards of electoral democracy
including
the rise of international expectations and standards for
electoral
democracy; including the rise of international election observing,
there is
closer international scrutiny of individual countries holding
elections.
Zimbabwe under ZANU PF is an electoral authoritarian
regime, given the
massive fraud in the 2000, 2002 and other elections
thereafter. We say so
because the country lacks an arena of contestation
sufficiently open, free
and fair so that the brutal party can readily be
removed from power if it is
no longer preferred by a plurality of the
people.
While an opposition victory is not impossible in a hybrid
regime like
ours, it requires a high level of opposition mobilisation, unity,
skill and
heroism far beyond what would normally be required for victory in
a
democracy. Often, too, it requires international observations
and
intervention to pre-empt and prevent or to expose the
electoral
manipulations and fraud of the scared ZANU PF regime.
And Zimbabwe today fits the model of a hegemonic party system in which
a
relatively institutionalised ruling party monopolises the political
arena
using coercion, patronage, media control and brutal laws to deny
other
political parties any real chance of competing for power.
The distinction between electoral democracy and electoral
authoritarianism
turns crucially on the freedom, fairness and meaningfulness
of elections, in
the ability of opposition parties and candidates to
campaign and in the
casting and counting of the vote.
Why do we say so? Elections can
only be said to be "free" when the
legal barriers to entry into the political
arena are low. And freedom to
campaign requires some considerable freedom of
speech, movement, assembly
and association in political life.
How many opposition candidates and supporters must be killed or
arrested
before one discerns a blatantly undemocratic pattern. In this
country,
election related killings have a long history and have risen to
alarming
levels from the year 2000 — corruption, criminality, murder and
kidnappings
heavily taint the electoral process, but we know that political
violence has
been the tool used by ZANU PF extensively to punish, terrorise
and demoralise
the opposition.
Therefore, ZANU PF has not been able to meet the
"minimum" criteria
for democracy. Elections can only be said to be fair when
they are
administered by a neutral authority and when the electoral
administration is
sufficiently competent and resourceful to take specific
precautions against
fraud and also when the police, military and courts treat
competing
candidates impartially throughout the process, when contenders all
have
access to the public media and when electoral rules do not
systematically
disadvantage the opposition, when independent monitoring of
the voting and
vote counting is allowed at all locations, when the secrecy of
the ballot is
protected; when the procedures for organising and counting the
vote are
transparent and known to all and when there are clear and
impartial
procedures for resolving complaints and disputes.
Electoral authoritarian regimes like ZANU PF do not practice democracy
but
resort regularly to naked repression. By organising periodic elections,
ZANU
PF tries to obtain at least a semblance of democratic legitimacy,
hoping to
satisfy internal and external actors.
And at the same time by
placing the elections under tight
authoritarian control, they try to cement
their continued hold on power.
ZANU PF’s dream is to reap the
fruits of electoral legitimacy without
running the risks of democratic
uncertainty. Balancing between electoral
control and electoral credibility,
they situate themselves in a nebulous
zone of structural ambivalence.
Democracy cannot simply be present or
absent. ZANU PF is plainly
undemocratic.
Elections are a necessary but not a sufficient
condition for modern
democracy. ZANU PF always manages to "get elections
right" but fails to
institutionalise other vital dimensions of democratic
constitutionalism such
as the rule of law, political accountability and
public deliberation.
In the common phrasing, elections must be
"free and fair" in order to
pass as democratic. Under electoral democracy,
contests comply with minimal
democratic norms and, under electoral
authoritaniasm like ZANU PF, they do
not.
Instead, the ZANU PF
regime hold some sort of elections. Some are
shams that nobody can take
seriously and others are occasions of struggle
than nobody can
ignore.
.. Frank Matandi-rotya is the MDC
shadow MP for Chikomba
constituency.
Fragmentation of the people’s resistance 11/21/2003 9:42:01 AM (GMT +2) AFTER the "No" vote of February 2000, there appears to be no common agenda within the pro-democracy movement. | |
Real and imagined methodological differences have plagued efforts to create a "popular front" and rally the pent-up forces of the angry Zimbabwean masses to meaningful and directional opposition to the ZANU PF hegemony. What is, in fact, happening is that the pro-democracy movement is beginning to be completely fragmented and people are now talking sectional politics. I would rather like to believe that this was foreseen long ago by the ZANU PF party and that it is, in fact, part of the programme. The unnecessary sectional particularism of the various pro-democracy political organisations in Zimbabwe tend to keep them apart, yet there is an exceptionally powerful and overriding reason why they should act together. It may be said that on the broader political front, opposition political leaders and civic leaders alike have not shown any overt signs of new thinking after the referendum; nor were the signs of disenchantment with the incumbent regime given a chance to crystallise into a positive approach. In fact, ZANU PF is now less in danger of collapse than it was in 2000. The fragmented, isolated and uncoordinated efforts by various political groups have failed to make the desired impact. Our refusal to club together and create a popular front has been the regime’s major ally to date. The "No" vote carried the day basically because the progressive movement was united and presented a common action front in the guise of the National Constitutional Assembly (NCA). There was no proper consensus as to the modus operandi in the post-referendum period. This was partly due to the totally unpredictable political development that succeeded the "No" vote, that is, the farm invasions that enjoyed varying interpretations. People would have expected the government to embark on an acceptable constitutional reform process that addressed the pertinent questions that led to the "No" vote; but alas, by some perverted logic, the "No" vote was interpreted by the government to mean a "Yes" vote for the Lancaster House Constitution. (I think it must now be called the ZANU PF constitution because the current document is now radically different from the original one.) The "No" vote gave a psychological advantage to the opposition and the entire pro-democracy movement ahead of the June 2000 general elections and this advantage could have been better utilised had we remained united and focused. After the referendum, the MDC became more concerned with the pending parliamentary elections and paid less attention to the constitutional question which basically intended to level the political playing field to their advantage. The belief was that the MDC would win against all odds. I believe it is just here where we find the seeds of the fragmentation of the people’s resistance. The NCA and other civic groups, on the other hand, insisted on constitutional reform before elections could be held, but because the MDC, which is one of the major member organisations of the NCA, progressively distanced themselves from the latter, the struggle was inevitably compromised. A compromise stance was adopted and the pro-democracy movement started advocating for "minimum standards" for free and fair elections. This was not vigorously pursued and elections were held under the current constitution and ZANU PF won with a simple parliamentary majority which was supplemented by the President’s constitutional power to appoint 30 MPs by special procedure. A battle lost. The consoling thing was that there was another battle looming — the Presidential election, which was widely believed to be the "big one". The MDC did not realise how much the current constitution was a disadvantage to them in the parliamentary elections. In their naivety, they failed to utilise the time between June 2000 and March 2002 to level the playing field through more militant demands for constitutional review. Again the belief was that the MDC would win against all odds. Just before the Presidential elections, President Mugabe used his powers to issue statutory instruments which substantially changed the electoral law regime to his advantage. The elections came and President Mugabe won in controversial circumstances. Another battle lost. A few months before the elections, some pro-democracy organisations, in their weak coalitions, adopted an alternative plan to be implemented in the event that President Mugabe rigged the elections. The alternative plan was that people will express their resentment in the streets, factories, industries, classrooms and even supermarkets and beerhalls. Before the final results were even announced, it was clear that the election was rigged and instead of implementing the alternative plan, Tsvangirai came out on television urging the restless masses to "remain calm"! As a result, the alternative plan was not implemented, partly because there was no consensus within the pro-democracy movement as to both its desirability and feasibility. It was also partly because it was advocated for, firstly, by people who never saw the need to implement it "because Mugabe will lose even if he rigs" and, secondly, by people who never believed in it in the first place. Paralysis gripped the nation in the immediate post-presidential election period. More than a year later, the MDC embarked on its ill-fated "final push" which raised serious questions about the party’s organisational capacity and mobilisation stategies. Yet another battle lost. After the Presidential election, the MDC adopted the re-run agenda coupled with a court challenge to the results of the election. Today, the re-run agenda has died a natural death as it has become clear that no such event will take place. Yet another battle lost. Realising the death of the re-run agenda, the MDC now emphasises dialogue with ZANU PF as the only viable way to extricate ourselves from the current socio-political and economic crisis. Already we can see that dialogue is being stifled and we are on the verge of losing yet another battle. I just hope we won’t lose the war. So what next? That is the question. Wait for the next general elections? Under the current constitution and electoral law regime? Oh, please! This is not to ridicule the MDC or to underplay efforts by other civic groups, but simply to demonstrate how false and artificial methodological differences are fragmenting the pro-democracy movement, resulting in loss of crucial political battles to the establishment. Perceived differences as to procedural issues on how best to deal with the crisis have generated lethal inter-group suspicions and tensions in the progressive movement, and worse still, utter confusion and uncertainty in the people, who don’t seem to know who to listen to anymore. This has shifted the focus from essentials of the struggles to ill-defined philosophical concepts which are both largely irrelevant and vaguely understood by the people. Just who can be said to be representative of the opinion and aspirations of the masses of Zimbabwean people struggling against the ZANU PF hegemony? Is it the MDC, NCA, Crisis in Zimbabwe Coalition, ZCTU, ZINASU, ZimRIGHTS, ZimCET, ZESN, Zimbabwean Liberators Platform, Transparency International etcetera; is it all of the above? or none of the above? With all due respect, it would appear that some of these organisations’ real concern is to keep themselves going as a group rather than being useful. In this sort of set-up one sees a perfect example of how the people’s resistance is being fragmented and stifled. Therefore, some opposition leaders and civic leaders are in the ultimate analysis, as guilty of the arrest of political progress as their ZANU PF counterparts for it is from some of them that the theory of gradualism emanates and this is what keeps the masses confused and always hoping that God will step down from heaven to solve their problems. One can rightly say the crisis in this country is in more than one way, a "Crisis of leadership" on both political divides. A lot of time and energy is spend by leaders of the pro-democracy movement in maintaining artificial methodological differences and in proving that their particular theory is the correct one, thereby being basically dishonest to themselves and to the struggle; to their counterparts and to the masses who are called upon to have faith in such people. The fact that we have differences of approach should not be allowed to cloud the issue. We have a responsibility not only to ourselves but also to the society from which we spring. No-one else will ever take the challenge up until we, of our own accord, accept the inevitable fact that ultimately the leadership of the masses in this country rests with us. If the current set-up continues, I predict that a time will come when this will prove very costly, not only in terms of money, but also in terms of the story we are trying to sell. The progressive movement must re-constitute, re-organise, re-invogorate and rejuvenate itself by the creation of a popular front. It is very possible for us to come up with a co-ordinated common action front for the attainment of particular objectives while at the same time remaining structurally autonomous as independent groups, organisationally and even ideologically. Those of us who advocate for a popular front seek to channel the pent-up forces of the angry Zimbabwean masses to meaningful and directional opposition. We want to ensure a singularity of purpose in the minds of the Zimbabwean people and to make possible total involvement of the masses in a struggle essentially theirs. The overall analysis, based on the Hegelian theory of dialectic materialism, is as follows: that since the thesis is ZANU PF hegemony there can only be one valid antithesis, that is, a solid block/unity of pro-democrary forces to counterbalance the scale. If Zimbabwe is going to be a democratic country where the ruling party, opposition political parties and civic organisations co-exist in harmony without fear of group exploitation, it is only when these two opposites have interplayed and produced a viable synthesis of ideas and a modus vivendi. We can never wage any struggle successfully without offering a strong counter-point to the ZANU PF hegemony that permeates our society so effectively. What we should always look at is that:
The criterion that must guide all of us is commitment. |
Minimising fast-track land reform damage
11/21/2003 9:43:03
AM (GMT +2)
THE report reveals that out of 134 452 recipients
allocated land, only
93 800 have taken up the allocated land. One wonders
where the figure of 300
000, as persistently claimed by part of the press, is
coming from.
Whereas the take-up is 97 percent in the A1 sector, a
paltry 66
percent among the A2 farmers have taken up possession, and a much
lower
number are actually making any attempt to physically farm the
allocated
properties, resulting in large tracks of Zimbabwe’s best land now
lying idle
for the third year.
Obviously, some people applied
for a farm as they believed it would
all be for "mahara"( free of charge)
without actually wanting to invest as
much as a dollar of their own money, or
to be involved in the tedious task
it is to go farming.
In my
opinion, the main damper on the enthusiasm among many A2
farmers, however, is
a total lack of security of tenure. No bank in the
country is willing to
accept a letter of offer signed by Joseph Made for as
long as the government
has not been able to secure the title deed over the
property.
According to international law, a title deed overrules any other
document,
even if such document is signed by somebody as prominent as the
president of
the country. This has recently come to light in Eastern Europe,
where the new
communistic rulers in the late 40s often chased the big
farmers off their
farms and other registered property and fast-tracked
landless workers onto
their property.
By the fall of the Iron Curtain, and in order to
regain recognition by
the international finance community, it now became
necessary for those
countries to offer all confiscated properties back to the
title deed
holders, or their estates.
With this situation in
mind, it might not be surprising that very few
of the new A2 farmers have
been willing to provide security in their posh
town houses, or other valuable
property. However, the whole idea in
selecting people with financial means
for the A2 sector was that they would
be self financing or have adequate
security to approach the private banking
sector and not rely, like the poor
A1 farmers, entirely on government aid
and hand- outs.
In the
case of hundreds of commercial farmers still holding on to
their title deeds,
but are finding it too risky to plough a few hundred
million Z$ into a new
crop for as long as there is imminent danger that some
kind of chefs, in most
cases with dubious papers and credentials, but still
exhibiting enough
political clout, to chase them off the property, and
"liberate" your standing
crop.
If Zimbabwe is not going to lose this valuable element of
human
resources, of proven dedicated and capable farmers, of which the
majority
were born here, speaks the local language fluently and are carrying
a
Zimbabwe passport, this situation must be redressed as a matter of
urgency.
Many have already gone to neighbouring countries to help
revitalise
their agricultural industry. If we want to keep the remaining +- 1
000
experienced commercial and agricultural businessmen here to make
their
contribution in turning the tide around again, it is time to act
speedily.
I will now turn to the key note in the
report, a semi-autonomous Land
Board, (LB).
If the right calibre
of dedicated professional people, able to keep
cheap party policy and
personal interest of any group or individuals out of
the decision making
process, are appointed to the board and will merely be
guided by the long
time benefit for Zimbabwe and her people, the LB will, in
my opinion, be able
to solve the land question within a framework that
basically will be
favourable to all Zimbabweans, them being genuine A1 and
A2 farmers, communal
and small-scale farmers, agricultural business people,
bankers, all the
workers in the country and, not least, the consuming
housewife, because
Zimbabwe’s prime land again will be utilised to its best
potential for food
production, resulting in shops and markets again being
full to the brim of
locally produced commodities at an affordable price.
Further, if
the LB is going to be totally apolitical and transparent,
it will undoubtly
become a big hit with the international donor community,
enabling it to bring
the whole agricultural industry, and thereby the
national economy, back on a
sound footing within the next two years.
Zimbabwe’s
total area is 39 million hectares and out of this, I am
estimating some 25
percent or 10 million hectares being prime land suited
for commercial
farming. Our population stands at 13 million, leaving each of
us with a
meagre 0,75 hectares if we went along with the philosophy that the
land
belongs to all of us, and each and every one must get his fair
share.
Such a move would, however, aggravate the food supply
situation and
leave most of the town folks starving. The first task of the LB
will,
therefore, be to identify all viable land in the country.
The next step will be to create a formula under which the LB will
become the
legal owner of such land, enabling them to lease it out to
prospective
farmers who are able to utilise such land to its best potential
and who are
prepared to pay a market related rent to the board. The LB will
actually be
fulfilling the role of custodian of the people of Zimbabwe, the
rightful
owners of the land and, as such, be obliged to get the best
possible return
from such land, both in terms of food security for the
people and a
meaningful return in the form of a market-related rent, of
which the revenue
must be ploughed back to the poor and less privileged
people. Such sentiments
will go down well with the donor community as we are
talking both about food
security and poverty alleviation, and as it further
will lead to a tremendous
increase in export revenue, enabling us to service
and pay back the loans
being granted.
It is my vision that we would by channelling the
land-rent back to the
people through the Rural District Councils (RDCs) and
would, by doing so, be
killing two birds with one stone.
The
RDCs have, during the later years, become an absolute farce,
without any
funding to carry out any of the social, medical and
educational
responsibilities they originally were designed to take care
of.
If allocated a reasonable chunk of the revenue from the LB,
they would
again be able to provide the rural folks with a reasonable service
and
regain the autonomy from central government they were supposed to have
at
their formation.
It is also my belief that the idea, seen
from a traditional and
cultural angle, would be acceptable to the rural folks
as any entrepreneur
doing successful business on their forefathers’ land has
only got the right
to do so for a limited period of time, and that some of
the rural children,
when they have developed the skills and capital to
undertake such a project,
would be able to take over a fair share of the land
for the next lease
period.
A market-related rent of 5-10
percent, depending on how much of the
infrastructure is being leased or
supplied by the tenant farmer, calculated
on expected revenue from the farm
in a normal year would, however, put a
stop to anybody wanting to take up a
lease if he is not certain in his mind
that he is going to farm the property
to its full potentials.
The very kingpin such a
scheme will be pivoting around is going to be
the lease-contract. It must be
absolutely clear — a legal instrument
formulated in a way it can be
registered with the Deeds Office as legal
tenure in the period of time for
which it is granted. A period of 49 years,
being the norm in Mozambique,
sounds fine for most, whereas anything shorter
than a normal farming stint of
say 30 years would be totally unacceptable.
To get this right first
time, input from the legal and financial
sector will be paramount, and also
from the potential lessees, them being
either individual farmers or corporate
agricultural business. In my opinion,
the majority of the commercial farmers
now sitting on the fence, clinging on
to their title deeds, would be willing
to exchange such title for a properly
constituted lease-contract in order to
go back to proper farming here in
Zimbabwe instead of starting afresh leasing
a farm in neighbouring
countries.
For the genuine A2 farmer who
more often than not only possesses a
letter of allocation, it would be very
attractive to get a legally
constituted lease from the LB and thereby be able
to source finance for
infrastructual development such as curing facilities,
water development,
greenhouses, milking parlours and not at least, up-to-date
professional
consultancy through the LB.
With regard to the
person who has only acquired farms for recreational
or investment purposes
but otherwise has no intention of utilising this
prime land to its potential,
I am afraid, and most Zimbabwean farmers agree,
that with its limited area of
prime land, Zimbabwe cannot afford that sort
of extravagance and such
investors will have to find land not classified for
commercial
agriculture.
The brief of an interim committee
So
where do we go from here? Are we, the stakeholders, supposed to
keep on
sitting on the fence scratching our back until the politicians have
sorted
out their mess and agreed amongst themselves on a new leader for the
ruling
party, to wait for the two major parties to come to talking terms
with each
other, in order to regain international credibility?
People are
starving; the economy is declining by some 14 percent pr
annum, and most of
Zimbabwe’s prime land is not being tilled. The time to
avoid another disaster
for the 2003/4 season is now long past and the time
to secure inputs for
2004/ 5 will soon be running out.
So in order to have the
administrative machinery ready as soon as the
political jig-saw puzzle
eventually falls in place, I humbly ask you,
Honourable Minister and newly
appointed chairman for the Land Steering
Committee, Mr John Nkomo, to act as
we are many who feel that you must be
the right man to get the ball
rolling.
Please consider as a matter of urgency the appointment of
an
apolitical interim board for the semi-autonomous Land Board, composed
of
highly professional people with practical experience in one or more of
the
subjects that will be within the area of the LB’s jurisdiction for a
period
of three to four months, with the following tasks:
A). To
identify all prime land in Zimbabwe suitable for
commercial
farming
B). By consultation with all the
stakeholders, to work out the
framework under which such land will become the
legal property of the LB
C). By consultation with stakeholders and
the legal fraternity to work
out a watertight lease-contract protecting the
interest of both the lessee
and lessor, and being acceptable to the banking
sector as collateral.
D). Make recommendations how to calculate,
charge and collect a market
related rent in order to avoid people leasing any
land, or more land than
they have got the capacity to utilise to its full
capacity.
E): Make recommendations how the revenue collected from
such land rent
will be benefit unfortunate Zimbabweans not able to take up
commercial land.
Should it be distributed through the Rural District Council,
Social Welfare
or what?
F). Make contact with the main donor
agencies, possibly starting with
the UNDP and get their input on how and
under which circumstances they would
be able and willing to contribute with a
meaningful participation in the
form of financing, human resources or other
inputs.
G) To make recommendations on the guidelines in selecting
the new
tenant farmers.
This could be like opening a can of
worms, as the criteria are
numerous and we are treading on very emotional
ground. Just a few of them
here: Educational standard, practical experience,
credit worthiness, age,
citizenship, will the one-farmer, one-farm policy
still apply, and further
will an applicant have to take up residence on the
farm, or will employment
of a resident manager with the laid down
qualifications suffice?
In my opinion, does a question recently
raised in the press by legal
professional Peter Kawonde illustrate the
complicity of the task: Will a
qualified young agriculturist have preference
in his/her own right, for a
professional judge, living in town, wanting to
employ the said agriculturist
as a manager?
FinGaz
Imports, food aid cut cereal deficit by 7%
Zhean Gwaze
11/21/2003 9:38:08 AM (GMT +2)
THE government’s commercial imports
and food aid have reduced the
total cereal gap for the 2003/04 marketing
season by seven percent, the
USAID-funded Famine Early Warning Systems
Network (FEWSNET) for the Southern
Africa Development Community has
said.
The gap fell from about 736 559 metric tonnes to about 685
000 metric
tonnes between mid-September and mid-October 2003.
"Total cereal imports from mid-September to mid-October 2003 are
estimated to
be just 53 000 metric tonnes. Planned cereal food aid imports
for the period
up to mid-November are less than 20 000 metric tonnes. These
cereal imports
reduce the cereal gap for the 2003/04 marketing year by only
seven percent to
about 685 000 metric tonnes," the FEWSNET said.
The food security
situation for the remainder of the current marketing
year (until March 2004)
is going to remain critical unless the government
and humanitarian agencies
are able to increase their food imports and
improve the local transportation
of food to needy communities, the early
warning unit said.
However, the government’s ability to procure more food abroad is
limited by
the country’s poor export performance, especially in agriculture.
This year tobacco failed to reach the $100 million kgs target due to a
poor
crop and support price and this further dampened prospects of an
increase in
foreign currency inflows.
Donor agencies like the World Food
Programme are suffering from a poor
resource pipeline that can only sustain
targeted feeding programmes, and not
general distribution, until December
2003.
According to FEWSNET, about 200 000 metric tonnes of the
2002/03
agricultural season’s estimated production of just over 800 000
metric
tonnes had been delivered to the Grain Marketing Board (GMB)
about
mid-October.
Reports in the state-owned media said that in
Mashonaland West
province, about 100 000 tonnes of maize is lying idle
because farmers cannot
transport it to the GMB.
Reports from
small-scale farmers throughout the country also indicate
that several
hectares of wheat out of the 40 000 hectares planted for the
winter crop have
not been harvested due to a shortage of equipment and
diesel.
This development also further compounds the issue of cereal shortages,
as
rains will affect the crop.
FEWSNET also noted that the food crisis
is being worsened by runaway
inflation, reduced employment opportunities and
low incomes.
"As the 2002/03 agricultural season’s meagre harvest
is being
consumed, many more households are without food and the price of
maize on
the parallel market has increased significantly, whenever it is
available."
FinGaz
‘Green Bombers’ a human time bomb
11/21/2003 9:46:33 AM (GMT +2)
MORE than a week ago, I stumbled on
the ZTV Programme FACE THE NATION
on which the Minister of Youth Development,
Gender and Employment Creation
was being interviewed on the subject of the
controversial National Youth
Service Training Programme.
Thinking that the minister would take advantage of the interview to
respond
to the many troubling questions that have been raised and allay the
fears
that have been expressed over the long-term ramifications of the
scheme, I
settled down to watch.
But — no prizes for guessing — I was
inevitably disappointed. Host
Masimba Musarira asked one or two important
questions but failed to press
the minister for specifics after Manyika gave
the usual stock answers
describing the initiative as a way to "teach youths
about our history and
where we came from".
When Musarira asked
why it had only become imperative to embark on the
programme now and not at
independence, the minister did a verbal tango,
which allowed him to get away
with evasive party mantras about patriotism
etc.
Manyika boasted
that 13 000 youths had so far graduated from training
centres and were
involved in various projects. I thought he made an
interesting revelation
when he said: "We can account for 99 percent of our
graduates."
This was in response to a question about the nationwide perception
that the
"Green Bombers", as these youths are notoriously known, were
responsible for
various heinous acts that have caused anguish in different
parts of
Zimbabwe.
Predictably, Musarira once again did not probe to
establish what had
happened to the one percent of the graduates that were not
accounted for.
One percent of 13 000 is quite a significant figure
considering the kind of
atrocities these youths have been accused of
perpetrating throughout the
country. Manyika should not have been allowed to
wriggle out without
explaining why any of the youths cannot be accounted for
in a programme that
is supposed to be so noble, well thought out and
carefully implemented. I
smell a rat.
Despite Manyika’s attempt
to paint a glowing picture, reports
indicating that all is not well with this
misnamed programme persist.
A Sunday paper, The Standard, published
a story in its issue of
October 12 indicating that the chickens may be coming
home to roost much
sooner than feared with respect to this human time
bomb.
The paper reported that the National Youth Service Training
Programme
was being blamed for an upsurge in cases of sexually transmitted
diseases at
the Kamativi Training Centre in Matabeleland North. The Standard
quoted an
official from Manyika’s Ministry as saying that drug and alcohol
abuse was
rampant at the centre.
"These youths need to be
counselled when they leave this centre. They
have been subjected to a life of
drugs and have been trained to be killers,"
he said. Despite Manyika’s
preference to bury his head in the sand, there is
no doubt that by teaching
these young people to lead a life of reckless
disregard for the rights of
others, drug abuse, debauchery and lawless
militancy, the government is
concocting a lethal cocktail of future
troubles.
Apart from
being unconcerned about how this group of anti-social young
people will be
rehabilitated once sanity is restored in this land, I bet
Manyika has never
considered the ramifications of having alleged rapists on
the government
payroll in this era of AIDS.
It would be catastrophic enough if the
harvest of death to be reaped
down the road were limited to the marauding
youths themselves. But even as
we speak, HIV is spreading silently among
countless of their victims. What
kind of national service is this, I would
like to know?
One of Manyika’s favourite defences of the "Green
Bombers" is to argue
that Zimbabwe is not the first country to have such a
set-up. What he
neglects to say is that national youth service programmes
like the one we
have in this country are a euphemism for violent militias
recruited mostly
to suppress dissent in dictatorial
environments.
Mao Tse Tung had his Red Guards during his Cultural
Revolution, Hitler
set up the SS (Schutz-Staffel), a paramilitary
organisation within the Nazi
party providing Hitler’s bodyguard and
concentration camp guards. Kamuzu
Banda had the Young Pioneers to buttress
his tyranny after he had declared
himself Life President and turned Malawi
into a police state.
The fact is that youth militias have rarely
metamorphosed into a
permanent, positive force in society beyond the reign of
the usually
authoritarian regime they serve.
In fact, they are
one of the first evils to go once a new political
dispensation comes into
force.
China no longer has Red Guards and European men now in their
70s are
still haunted and still trying to live down the shame of their
involvement
in Hitler’s SS during the holocaust. The young Pioneers faded
into history
with the end of Kamuzu Banda’s dictatorship.
In
Spain, the Movimiento, dictator Francisco Franco’s principal
instrument for
the control of political thought, had to be dismantled when
King Juan Carlos
ascended to the throne in 1977 and set about establishing
democratic
rule.
I could quote countless other examples but the ones cited
above
demonstrate beyond doubt the transient nature of militias.
What should concern Manyika and the rest of his colleagues in
government is
whether extending their hold on power that little bit longer
justifies the
catastrophe they are setting in motion through the
exploitation of these
young people.
Some churches and civic organisations have called for
the dismantling
of the National Youth Service Programme so that
rehabilitation of the
participants can begin now. That these calls have
fallen on deaf ears is a
tragedy in itself.
VOA
Emergency Measures Make Life Easier for Zimbabweans
Tendai
Maphosa
Harare
21 Nov 2003, 16:50 UTC
The lines for basic
foodstuffs and bank notes have disappeared in Zimbabwe,
at least for the time
being, after the government took emergency measures.
But, the lines of people
wanting to leave the crisis-ridden country are
getting longer.
At the
British High Commission in Harare, an official says more than 100
visa
applications are processed daily. Two thirds of the visa requests
are
granted.
So many Zimbabweans have moved to London that they have
started calling it
Harare-North.
The British government responded to
the increased number of Zimbabweans
wanting to go to Britain by introducing a
visa regime in 2002.
For many of the would-be emigrants, economics was
the main motivation, as
they tried to flee the country's deepening economic
crisis. But for many
others, the government's policies toward the press, the
political opposition
and human rights activists led them to seek political
asylum.
The British government charged that some of those leaving
Zimbabwe under the
guise of seeking political asylum were actually trying to
move to Britain
for economic reasons.
Zimbabweans are also heading to
other destinations.
Many try to go to South Africa. But the legal process
has gotten more
difficult, with tightened visa procedures, including a
requirement that the
applicant have a sufficient amount of South African
currency, which is very
hard to get in Zimbabwe.
But the visa
regulations mean little to thousands of Zimbabweans who risk
life and limb by
wading across the crocodile-infested Limpopo River, which
forms the border
between South Africa and Zimbabwe. The illegal immigrants
end up working on
farms, or doing other badly paid menial jobs in South
Africa.
The
South African Department of Home Affairs told the online news service
CNS
News that the police arrest about 300 illegal Zimbabwean immigrants
every
day.
Another popular destination is Botswana, where Zimbabweans do not
need a
visa for short-term entry. Thousands are abusing the privilege
by
overstaying the dates on their entry stamps to look for work. Many just
walk
across the border. According to the London-based newsletter ZW-News
report,
the Botswana immigration department says 125,000 Zimbabweans cross
into
Botswana every month.
The Botswana government is putting up an
electrified fence along the border.
The fence is seen as an attempt to
contain the 'border jumpers,' as the
illegal immigrants are known.
But
the Botswana government says it is more worried about another kind of
'border
jumper' from Zimbabwe. The government says the fence is designed to
prevent
Zimbabwean animals from crossing the border, and potentially
infecting its
herds with foot and mouth disease. There have been some
outbreaks of the
disease on the Zimbabwean side of the border, and beef is
one of Botswana's
biggest foreign currency earners.
Another Cash Crisis Looming
Financial Gazette
(Harare)
November 21, 2003
Posted to the web November 21,
2003
Givemore Nyanhi
Harare
ANOTHER severe cash crisis is
looming and is expected to hit the country by
Christmas this year as
government fails to douse the flames of runaway
inflation, analysts said this
week.
Speaking at a labour relations briefing organised by the Institute
of
Personnel Management of Zimbabwe (IPMZ) John Robertson, an
economic
consultant, said that when prices double, the amount of cash in
circulation
should also double to offset any shortages in money
supply.
"There was about $100 billion in circulation in June this
year, prices
doubled in September and cash circulation did not double to
offset any
shortages, prices are more likely to double this December and
again there
are no major plans to address the shortages," Robertson
said.
Robertson said: "In 1997, consumer prices doubled after 44 months;
in 2000,
they doubled after 16 months and in 2002, doubled after seven
months. This
shows a steady decline in the value of the Zimbabwe
dollar."
John Makumbe, Transparency International Zimbabwe (TIZ)
chairman, speaking
at a separate conference held by the corruption watchdog
in Harare last
week, said that asset stripping by people in power would go on
eroding the
economy of this country if an independent anti-corruption
commission was not
set up.
"With the parallel market booming and with
the people in power responsible
for the nation's welfare benefiting from the
system, it is very clear that
the cash crisis will return to haunt us by
Christmas," he said.
Makumbe said the forced land reform programme
had effectively led to assets
loosing their original value.
Zimbabwe
is still recovering from the effects of the cash shortages that hit
the
country for over three months charac-terised by an acute shortage of
bank
notes and long winding queues that brought most businesses to a halt.
Daily News
Labour leaders plot next course of action
Date:21-Nov, 2003
LABOUR and civic leaders released from police
detention yesterday are
expected to meet today to discuss their future course
of action, according
to Zimbabwe Congress of Trade Unions (ZCTU) secretary
general Wellington
Chibhebhe.
More than 80 heads of civic and
labour organisations were arrested on
Tuesday for planning mass
demonstrations to protest high taxation, worsening
poverty and human rights
abuses.
Chibhebhe said the organisations would meet to determine if
they could
proceed with their mass protests, which were thwarted by the
police early
this week.
A Harare magistrate yesterday freed some
of the protesters on free
bail.
ZCTU officials said their
release was delayed by confusion within the
police and state attorneys about
what charges to bring against them.
Some members of the group were
told on Wednesday they would be charged
with the lesser offence of
obstructing traffic in downtown Harare.
More Switch to Cheaper Dot Com Mail
Financial Gazette
(Harare)
November 21, 2003
Posted to the web November 21,
2003
Givemore Nyanhi
Harare
ZIMBABWE'S young Internet café
industry continues to grow even under tight
economic conditions as more
people turn to the Internet, the cheapest means
of
communication.
"Most of our patrons are teachers, nurses and people
looking for greener
pastures abroad as the cost of living becomes too
expensive in the country,"
said a worker for a leading Internet café in the
city centre. In Harare
alone, the numbers of Internet service cafés has shot
up incredibly over the
past two years.
Internet provides the easiest
and cheapest way of communicating between
Zimbabweans in the country and
their relatives who have fled Zimbabwe's
worsening political and economic
morass as the telephone and postal charges
become unaffordable.
Harare
boasts of over 20 thriving Internet cafés, and others hidden in the
backrooms
of most buildings, that are making brisk business everyday with
the prospect
of more cafés opening soon.
Some of the major cyber cafés in the city
centre include Quick n' Easy,
InTouch, DC Africa, Telco and the state
operated ComOne.
"It is easy to tell that the rise in Internet use has a
lot to do with the
mass exodus of locals leaving for greener pastures. The
easiest way of
keeping in touch is through the Internet and it will remain
like this for so
long as the unstable economic and political situation
degenerates," said one
Quick n' Easy worker.
Last year, Zimbabwe was
recorded among the top 11 countries with substantial
Internet usage with more
than 35 000 dial-up Internet subscribers who have
accounts with the country's
more than five internet service providers
(ISPs). Some of these Internet
service providers are Africaonline, Ecoweb,
Telconet, Zimbabwe Online, Zimweb
and ComOne.
The charge for sending or receiving an electronic message
swings between $10
and $30 a minute and all cafés allow subscribers to spend
a minimum of 10
minutes while an international call costs around $500 per
minute.
Some cafés have come up with customer friendly packages that
allow
subscribers to become members if they pay for more than 10 hours in
advance
and then enjoy special discount rates and more surfing
time.
Quick n' Easy Internet café with three cafes in and around the city
centre
is tightlipped about its operations but it is reliably understood that
the
hugely successful company is owned by a consortium of businessmen
with
connections in South Africa.
However, experts in the field
revealed that although cafés were enjoying
brisk business, the country was
unlikely to go on experiencing new entrants
since the current economic regime
was becoming highly restrictive as the
costs of computers skyrocket.
A
new computer now costs around $4 million and the prices fluctuate on a
daily
basis.
Zimbabwe Internet Service Providers Association (ZISPA) chairman
Shadreck
Nkala said in terms of public access to the Internet, Zimbabwe was
far ahead
of South Africa.
" Zimbabwe only lags behind South Africa
because their telecommunications
network is bigger than ours, hence more
companies subscribe to the Internet
while in Zimbabwe the figure is less,"
Nkala said.
He said, however, on the public sphere, there was more
public Internet use
relying on the small number of Internet service
providers. "There has been a
very dramatic upsurge in the number of public
Internet users and the trend
is likely to keep on rising," he
said.
There are over four million Internet users in Africa, with the bulk
of them,
over 60 percent, found in Zimbabwe and South Africa alone while
North Africa
accounts for more than 250 000, and the reminder in the other 50
countries
on the continent.
Agricultural Output Set to Decline By 50 Percent
Financial
Gazette (Harare)
November 21, 2003
Posted to the web November 21,
2003
Zhean Gwaze
Harare
ZIMBABWE'S agricultural sector is
expected to decline by as much as 50
percent next year unless stability is
restored to the industry, which forms
the country's economic
backbone.
Agriculture accounts for 40 percent of Zimbabwe's economy and
provides at
least 60 percent of the inputs used in the manufacturing
sector.
The government has made it clear that it does not have sufficient
funds to
finance the 2003/04 agricultural season, brewing a cloud of
uncertainty
despite predictions of a favourable rain season by the
Meteorological
Srevice.
New and old farmers are still struggling to
acquire seed, fertiliser and
fuel, one month after the beginning of the
cropping season.
Economic analysts and farmers' representatives have
urged the government to
come up with strategic policies to turn around the
sector before it faces
total collapse.
"There are prospects that the
sector will fall by that margin because there
is no fuel, seed and fertiliser
to enable farming to commence this year,"
said economic consultant John
Robertson.
"Instead the government has been giving out $200 000 to A1 and
A2 model
farmers to procure inputs which are not available. Eventually, the
farmers
will convert the money to personal use and the vicious circle of
poverty
continues. It all adds up to absolute disaster."
Receipts from
tobacco, which were meant to breathe new life into the
country's foreign
currency situation, have plummeted by 51 percent compared
to last
year.
Tobacco, which is geared for the manufactured international leaf
market, has
been Zimbabwe's single largest export earner, contributing a
third of the
nation's annual foreign exchange receipts.
But already
the 2002/2003 tobacco season ended on a low key with a total 81
million kgs
of the flue-cured crop valued at about US$183 million (about
$151.5) being
sold at the auction floors compared to about double the
previous
season.
Commercial Farmers' Union president Douglas Taylor-Freeme
added:
"Agriculture is no longer producing meaningful exports and very soon
other
sectors will outdo its performance."
The Famine Early Warning
Systems Network has warned that the country would
produce less than 66
percent of its food requirements of 1.2 million metric
tonnes due to input
shortages.
Fertiliser companies have issued a joint statement that they
will not be
able to meet demand because of shortage of foreign currency to
procure raw
materials.
The country's wheat production has declined to
less than 150 000 tonnes
against a national requirement of 400 000 tonnes.
The land reform programme
caused the demand for fertiliser to shoot up from
400 000 tonnes to one
million.
The government, which is faced with the
task of importing adequate medical
drugs, needs to import in excess of 30 000
tonnes of seed to augment local
supplies. Seed costs about US$2 000 a
tonne.
"The farmers will produce one of the worst crops. Those who manage
to
harvest will not enjoy the fruits of their labour as the crop will
be
stolen," Robertson warned.
The national herd is also said to have
dwindled from 5.1 million in 1998 to
250 000 this year due to drought,
foot-and-mouth disease, shortages of stock
feeds and loss of stock by most
farmers due to the land reform programme.
Officials from the Cattle
Producers' Association said that most farmers
could not afford to restock
because they could not afford to buy stock
feeds, which were pegged at about
$750 000 per tonne and cost up to $2
million to import.
Zimbabwe, a
key exporter of beef to the lucrative European Union market, has
since
stopped exporting beef to the economic bloc and regional countries
because of
the prevalence of the deadly foot-and-mouth disease.
The country is still
exporting limited beef to the Democratic Republic of
the Congo although the
export figures are not clear.
Indigenous Commercial Farmers' Union
president Davidson Mugabe said it was
imperative for the government to put in
place policies that would ensure
viability to both farmers and co-industry
players.
"The agricultural sector should be handled in a holistic manner.
The
government should come up with policies that ensure that every player in
the
sector is satisfied while at the same time production is being
maximised,"
said Mugabe.
The cotton industry, which earned US$150
million in foreign exchange
receipts last year, is faced with collapse as the
government dithers in
placing measures to safeguard the interests of major
players in the sector.
The Cotton Company of Zimbabwe and FSI Agricom
applied to the government to
place a regulatory framework for the industry to
curb against side
marketing.
Lands and Agriculture Minister Joseph
Made has not responded, a move that is
bound to reduce the number of cotton
producers as the major players have
threatened to withdraw
funding.
Made was not immediately available for comment.
Another
economist said: "We will struggle to get through this year, and we
will
continue experiencing scarcities in essential imports due to shortages
of
foreign currency."
Farmers unions' presidents said they were looking
forward to an early
announcement of an increased support price when Finance
Minister Herbert
Murerwa presents the 2004 budget on November 20.
"The
immediate review of the support price will return faith among growers
and
confidence among investors," one farmers' union leader said.
"The
government should put experienced farmers back on the land because
issuing
agri-bonds that are not being bought does not add value to the
sector," one
economist said.
Agri-bonds are money market instruments being used by the
government to
raise money for resettled farmers.
Mail and Guardian
'Abuja is not a big issue'
Benhilda
Chanetsa
21 November 2003 09:24
Zimbabwe President
Robert Mugabe may or may not have squeezed his way into
the Commonwealth
Heads of Government Meeting (Chogm) set for Abuja, Nigeria,
early next month
after talks with Chogm host President Olusegun Obasanjo
this week.
But
his attendance is irrelevant to the real struggle going on inside
the
country, say Mugabe watchers.
A day after Obasanjo’s visit, the
Zimbabwe Congress of Trade Unions (ZCTU)
and its civic partners took to the
streets to protest continued human rights
abuses and the deteriorating
economic situation — one that has seen
inflation rise to 525% (see story
below), unemployment to 80% and a foreign
currency crisis that has led to a
clampdown on illegal forex and gold
dealers but without netting sufficient
forex resources for fuel and other
requirements. A paltry $2-million worth of
forex is said to have been
received in early November, while about 40% of the
gold being produced is
currently coming in.
The demonstration led to
more than 400 arrests, including those of top ZCTU
and civic group leaders
who were charged with violating the notorious Public
Order and Security Act,
which seeks to stifle perceived anti-Mugabe protests
by requiring that they
receive police sanction. There were reports of
beatings by police during the
arrests and these, the ZCTU said, demonstrated
the continuing internal
crisis.
Said Colin Gwiyo, the deputy secretary general of the ZCTU: “The demo
takes
our message further. Abuja is not a big issue. With or without
Obasanjo,
human rights are being violated. Whatever happens, the situation is
here,
now.”
The ZCTU has called for a two-day strike on November 21
and 22 to demand the
release of those arrested. The start of the strike will
coincide with
Finance Minister Herbert Murerwa’s Budget speech.
More
protests are planned for Human Rights Day on December 10, when the
crisis is
expected to have worsened. The protesters are also expected to
target the
National Youth Service Programme believed to be churning out
youths
responsible for much of the election violence.
Zimbabwe was suspended
from the Commonwealth for a year after Mugabe’s March
2002 presidential
election victory, dubbed fraudulent by the opposition
Movement for Democratic
Change (MDC) and the Commonwealth and Western
nations, but largely endorsed
by Asian and African countries.
The suspension has remained in place
because of reports of continued human
rights abuses such as those reportedly
perpetrated against demonstrators
this week. However, Mugabe still views
Zimbabwe’s suspension as “a racist
plot” cooked up by the white Commonwealth
because of his seizure of
white-owned farm land.
Mugabe’s attendance at
Chogm is still far from certain, however.
Although he confidently
informed the state media “we look forward to
attending Chogm, Abuja”,
Obasanjo was more circumspect. After talks with
Mugabe and MDC leader Morgan
Tsvangirai he announced that he would seek
wider consultation before a
decision could be taken on Zimbabwe’s
attendance.
Professor Heneri
Dzinotyiwei of the University of Zimbabwe said: “It’s not
obvious, really,
that he [Mugabe] will be invited. It’s still very much
hanging in the air,
but [President Thabo] Mbeki and Obasanjo would wish for
Zimbabwe’s problems
to be settled internally rather than externally.” He
added that it would be
to the MDC’s advantage to focus on the internal
crisis.
MDC party
spokesperson Paul Themba Nyathi said Mugabe’s attendance at Chogm
was of “no
consequence”, that the real struggle the MDC was concerned with
was “for the
people of Zimbabwe” and the “piles and piles of applications”
it was
receiving daily were testimony to the party’s growing popularity
among the
people.
He said the MDC was continuing as before and nothing had changed.
“Mugabe’s
attendance is not the issue [the issue is] rather the inflation,
the
unemployment, the fact that one in three have no access to
anti-retrovirals
and the government’s failure to provide maize seed. These
are the issues of
immediate concern, not Abuja, which is 6 000km away,” he
said, adding that
his party had in no way been weakened by the Obasanjo
visit.
The state-owned Herald newspaper reported that Obasanjo had in
talks with
Mugabe mentioned that he had witnessed a “changed, mellow”
Tsvangirai.
However, when contacted for comment, Tsvangirai denied that he
was softening
towards the idea of a government of national unity and insisted
that the MDC
would continue as before with its court challenge: “How can
there be a
government of national unity when we have not negotiated?” he
asked.
The MDC’s court petition against Mugabe’s 2002 election victory
began on
November 3, but was temporarily put on hold the following day to
give the
judge time to study the initial submissions.
David Coltart,
the MDC secretary for legal affairs, believes that it was
placed before the
courts “overwhelming arguments. There is no other peaceful
lawful action at
our disposal. As we’ve said in the past, if there’s
meaningful progress, we
will consider suspending the court proceedings, and
if the discussions yield
a final agreement which is irreversible and
endorsed by the international
community”. — Africa Media Online